From The Archives:
Silent Hill 2 Plot Analysis
A long-form analysis on one of the greatest horror games ever made.
Why The Christmas Shopping Season is Worse Every Year
Everyone hates Black Friday sales. Even retailers! So why does it exist?
Here is a 13 part series where I talk about programming games, programming languages, and programming problems.
Why I Hated Resident Evil 4
Ever wonder how seemingly sane people can hate popular games? It can happen!
Quakecon Keynote 2013 Annotated
An interesting but technically dense talk about gaming technology. I translate it for the non-coders.
139 thoughts on “DM of the Rings LXXX:
Seems like every new episode there’s someone who tells you that it’s the new best.
This. Is. The. New. Best.
I figuratively bust a gut laughing so hard.
Thank you, thank you.
Lol great comic keep it up
all elves are ladies. seems that way in the PHB.
Gotta love Aragon stairing at Haldir’s chest… “There once was an allianc… HEY! My eyes are up here!”
I think I have a hernia from laughing. Thanks for bringin’ the funny– I mean, “ouch”.
Shame shame Shamus THE Great!
I don’t care if it is redundant because its been done already.
IM WAITING ON AN STD ROLL…..OR
some blondie elf to give Aragon a swift kick! LOL!
And profoundly disturbing. Someone’s got a prettyboy elf fetish.
What a *hotty*
It’s so nice to see Aragorn getting into the role-playing, though.
GIMLI: “The thing is, Aragorn thought your Elf was a lady.”
LEGOLAS: “I can understand that!”
…aaaand there it is.
You know, for someone who’s always concerned with sex, ya’ figga’ Aragorn would know by now how to tell the difference between women & elves. Maybe that’s why artists always have women in chain mail bikinis, just so players like Aragorn won’t get confused ( Bikini = babe. Covered = guy)
Bikini = babe. Covered = guy
While it’s a generalization, that’s an unfortunate truth. You’ll have to remember that a majority of RPG fandom is male. And sex sells. Female personas have to look good to be memorable. The chainmail bikini helps.
Generally, female fantasy costumes of that nature have no true function. They don’t protect against the elements. It’s not comfortable – scale and chainmail can pinch the skin and snag hair unless there’s cloth padding (or the female shaves certain… areas). They provide no armor value whatsoever (exposed thighs and abdomens being a favorite theme for females).
It’s there to make the male gawk and go “Yep. That’s a babe.”
Despite my preachings of course, I am a guy, and while I believe that such attire is non-functional, I will also be the first to admit that it IS nice to look at.
“Maybe that's why artists always have women in chain mail bikinis, just so players like Aragorn won't get confused ( Bikini = babe. Covered = guy)”
No.. I think that the artists probably have their own reasons for drawing all the women that way
Player Character: An imaginary creation which thinks the world revolves around it, when in fact the world really revolves around the DM’s storyline. Brings about as much harmony to the table as an air horn brings to a symphony.
Or maybe a vuvuzela?
Great comic, tho.
As a female gamer….
Well, I liked the look of the chainmail bikini…I’ve usually used a variantion thereof, like a druid being in a hide bikini, or a rogue in a leather catsuit. So it’s not just the guys who propagate the stereotype, I mean look at Xena, am I the only one who watched that show and saw that the more Gabrielle became a hero, the less clothes she was wearing? Until she was wearing less than Xena? So yeah…just my 2 cents, and on a side note….Can I have your baby Seamus?! You rock!
The look of open lust in Aragorn’s eyes is truly disturbing… I’m never going to watch those movies in the same way.
Thanks, Shamus! :)
Sixth panel: should be “ourselves,” not “outselves.” Unless Aragorn is making a Freudian slip — that’s some multi-layered humor.
Chainmail bikinis can’t be that bad, there’s no shortage of real girls that wear them to SCA events and Conventions. But I don’t think they’re wearing them to turn aside sword cuts. Just the opposite, in some cases…
Oh man thats funny! I missed the first half of the comments from laughing so long.
STAY BACK SHE DEVIL lol
good stuff man, keep it up
blackjack! i mean great strip today… lol have a shot of arigorn huggin his “babe” later…good times
Ah, we see Aragormless’s Keen Ranger Senses(TM) at work again.
Clearly Aragorn’s player has been in too many classic Gary Gygax modules, where the appearance of a buxom blonde was invariably followed by the party’s gruesome demise – whether the blonde herself was a succubus, rakshasa, doppelganger or other shapeshifter, or just an agent of evil determined to betray the party at her earliest opportunity.
Perhaps being an English major, a shoe salesman and a hardcore grognard didn’t earn Gary a lot of popularity with the ladies, and he was a tad bitter?
Comments about making Helms Deep-style scenery out of Lego gave me the germ of an idea for DMotR. Have the story at some point in an elaborate set (I would say Gondor but the only PC who gets to go there before the wheels come off has already left to play either Star Wars or Mech Warrior) roughly transition from in-story scenery to DVD-extra “behind the scenes” footage of the same thing under construction. When the players do a “What the Heck?”, have the DM explain that they have to use some imagination, there being only so much that can be achieved with Lego, egg-cartons and stacks of unused dice. Then transition back into the film footage for the sarcastic punchlines.
PS I was at I-Con over the weekend and picked up some new dice. Feeling I hadn’t been entirely fair, I swallowed deeply and added an orange D20 to the collection.
It is still the most hideous thing I have seen in lo these many years, and nowhere near as clear to read as the white, yellow or blue D20’s I bought at the same time.
Yeah , yeah, but does it roll high, Steve?
Despite all the chain mail bikinis seen at the Ren Faire & in spite of all my encouragement (ie pleading), my wife still won’t wear one…unless (she claims) I develop the body that allows me to wear the barbarian loin-cloth…
As someone who once wore a chainmail minidress to a Con let me also add that it’s freaking cold!
Woerlan Says: scale and chainmail can pinch the skin and snag hair unless there's cloth padding
Watch the slash fans go WILD at this one. :)
Excellent work, Shamus, as always. I love this strip!
Panels 6 and 7… priceless!
Re to Mysti:
one, The less you were, the lees you are gonna be hit.
Thus, the chainmail bikini.
Two, Muchken(sp) Was a vary good Game.
I know i cant spell, That Good old retatard(sp) classes for you
Just when I thought the ‘Aragorn thinks pretty boy elves are girls’ running gag had run out of steam, this comic appears and totally rekindles how hilarious it is.
I love it!
Also, I’m reminded of a bard NPC that I tried very hard to make look and act “dashing”. He had stylish clothes, a big hat with a feather, a lute, goatee and spoke as poetically as possible.
… Everyone in my game called him a fag for as long as he was there. -_-;
Blindeye, sounds like you needed a more mature gaming group. *eyeroll*
I love the look on Haldir in the speechless reaction panel.
You’ve gotta admit that Haldir does look an awful lot like Jan Brady.
As another female gamer who played about half male and half female characters, my females always wore armor — real armor — thanks very much. [eyeroll] And the young women who wear chainmail bikinis or whatever to cons and Faire and SCA events aren’t expecting to fight in it; it has quite a different purpose.
These are the same kinds of women who take their lives in their hands dancing in four inch spike heels because they attract guys. They’re the same kinds of women who corsetted themselves down to 15 inches in the 19th century, or had their floating ribs surgically removed in the very early 20th (back when anesthetics sucked, remember, and surgical patients still had a decent chance of dying of infection). You’ll always find a minority who are willing to put up with pain, discomfort and even mutilation for the sake of being “attractive.” But let’s not pretend it’s at all functional, or that anything close to all women are interested in that sort of thing.
I have to say, I find it hard to take anything seriously when said with that much venom…
Venom? I interpreted AngiePen’s comment as having equal parts mild annoyance and resignation. Not saying you can’t disagree with me, course you can. I think she’s making solid points. You get this continuum of people who put differing values on “attractiveness.” Some people take it really really far and do the things Angie listed, 15-inch corsets, floating rib removals, all that stuff. Some do the opposite and find it distasteful to emphasise physical attractiveness when they’re trying to knuckle down and take a game or a job seriously. And some are happier combining both. Most of my female friends are 100% fine with both, though I think all three are valid. Do what feels right, you know?
That DM seriously need to call out “a force of MALE elves!”.
Aragorn is on the right track, only Haldir isn’t there to destroy the enitire party… He’s there to distract Aragorn whilst I rob him blind and backstab him to death! Muahahahahahahahaha.
The look Aragorn is giving Haldir in panel 9 is easily the most disturbing things about this comic.
I’ve been following this for a while, and I just wanted to speak up and say how utterly, utterly awesome it is. Especially this one, which is hysterical! I wonder if the DM will ever learn to specify gender in his character descriptions?
“I wonder if the DM will ever learn to specify gender in his character descriptions?”
Probably not. The default gender in RPGs seems to be male. Unless stated otherwise, NPCs are male when brought to the player’s attention. Sometimes, the descriptor gives away the gender (ex. witch, sorceress, queen) but otherwise you tend to assume it’s male.
With elves… well, you can never be too sure. Even when you think they’re male… they may be… not… male.
Still trying to get Aragorn’s frozen expression out of my mind. When movement gets frozen into a single image like that, you start to lose context pf the original situation. Something Shamus seems to be a master of manipulating. ^_^
“Generally, female fantasy costumes of that nature have no true function.”
Au contraire! “Sonja tosses aside her cloak, revealing the mighty chain mail bikini, an item of wonderous enchantment. Her opponent gawks, fixated on the flimsy, yet oh so shiny garment; only then notices the hilt sticking out from his chest. His eyes bug out even farther, then cloud over…”
Just to blow my own horn a bit with regards to the whole chainmail bikini debate, I’d like to point out that there are some of us guys who do make a point of having female characters wear something practical. In City of Heroes (to jump genres) you have an entire category of costume options not available to men- all of them being variants on the standard outfit but showing lots of bare skin. There’s also three options for skirts- upper thigh, mid thigh, and schoolmarm (ankle-length with a petticoat underneath). I can quite proudly claim that my one female character there has foregone all the above in favor of heavy leathers, and while she does have high heels (the only option with the sort of boot I wanted) I’ve made it a point that she doesn’t actually walk on them- she specifically has a power to allow her to remain stable in the shoes, and glide along on a field of mystic energy.
It’s also worth noting that I decided on this outfit after seeing a typical miniskirt-and-cutouts heroine get knocked flat while adventuring in the sewers. I figure it’s bad enough you have to wade through that stuff, getting it inside your costume is -not- an option.
Hah, another awesome comic.
I’d like to echo the poster above me. All my female characters (and I’m a guy) will always be fully dressed when adventuring. They might change for social gatherings, but work is work.
I just love the way the video / narration gets paused whenever the DM has to make a sanity check. LMAO — this strip never fails to make my morning.
Hah, there’s a reason that the optional skill “elven gender identification” was such a long-running gag in our various campaigns…
And in some cases I think even I needed it while watching LotRs, and probably failed a few checks. And I’m a girl with an eye for the pretty-boy elven type.
“Probably not. The default gender in RPGs seems to be male. Unless stated otherwise, NPCs are male when brought to the player's attention.”
Oh yeah, I remember bringing that to my husband/GM’s attention.
“It’s too bad there are no women in your world.”
“What?! There are plenty of women!”
“Really? How many of the named NPCs we’ve met in the last 3 months were female?”
“… There was that hag you fought…”
After that, every 5th or 10th NPC was described with “Oh, and they’re FEMALE”. I always thanked him for making the effort. ;)
Wow. By the look on his face, I don’t think Haldir has ever been called a “smouldering temptress” before.
Jolly brilliant, as always.
Oh man this one is great! Every single shot of Aragorn is perfect…especially when he is checking out Haldir’s chest in panel 9. And right after he said he wouldn’t fall for ‘her’ she-devil charms too.
I agree heartily with the post above. Shamus, you have truly mastered the art of the desperate pause when the players throw the DM off track.
Long live DM of the Rings!
I believe that only stupid people use those “revealing” clothing. Some people (girls) actually have brains. The stupid ones who do are as before mentioned, stupid. They have no point. If you were going to a DANGEROUS place, it would at least be a BIT smart to bring true armor. Many people won’t be distracted by that kind of thing anyways. You have to be practical. Also, there are many people who feel the same way as me.
If any of you geeks want to read an academic paper on females in gaming, check out:
There aren’t any pictures, but it does have this passage:
Especially in medieval fantasy games, women in general have been depicted as either helpless and shapely, or sexy and shapely””distressed gentlewomen to be rescued or tavern wenches to be wenched with. Another common depiction of female characters, and perhaps the most disturbing to dedicated female gamers, is the warrior woman in a “chainmail bikini”””an under-dressed fighter who seems more intent on wielding her breasts and buttocks than her broadsword. Although the 3rd edition AD&D handbooks, as well as the current books of many other games, picture females more sensibly dressed and occupied in game-related activities, thirty years of subservience and cheesecake have left their mark on women's and men's perceptions of gaming and on male/female RPG interactions.
PS-I’m a guy, and it’s hilarious strips like this that remind me why I stopped playing D&D.
Wait a minute….. Someone wrote an “academic paper” on females in gaming?!?! What the F@*K was your major exactly in? And more importantly what the hell was your thesis?
Biology 202, “Sociophobes and estrogen, it’s not just a man’s problem anymore.”
Psychology Doctorate ” Female compatibility in the world of Nerds”
Seriously…. who writes an academic paper on a tiny sub-culture within an even smaller sub–culture, that’s almost totally North American, and isn’t even that interesting to begin with?
Most people find gaming boring nd pointless, I can’t imagine the apathy towards reading about ONLY it.
sheeeesh…. maybe he couldn’t find a good game of gurps around…
There are plenty of European gamers.
Everybody needs a thesis in academia…maybe these writers were also gamers and wanted to combine both their interests? Win-win.
And on a semi-related note…. I for one, am a big supporter of women in chain mail skirts, leather skirts, plate mail bras…. and well… I guess I’m a fan of scantily clad women in general, style and materials be damned.
Note about chain mail bikinis: WEAR SUNSCREEN, don’t forget the lining (chafing, pinching, and other things happen in embarrassing areas) and be careful when it’s warm out…ouchies!
Besides, as any true woman warrior in the SCA or other live-combat group can tell you, REAL women know what waffle-bruises are…!
“These are the same kinds of women who take their lives in their hands dancing in four inch spike heels because they attract guys.”
Why do you think guys ride motorcycles?
It’s the tail of the peacock… “My genes are so fit, I can act like an idiot and still survive!”
Oh, wow. For the win. Standalone, this strip is great — I would so love someone to show the Aragorn actor panels 6 & 7 — but coming after previous strips (not only Legolass, but also how “yellow-haired and fair” is of COURSE all the Aragorn-player needs to hear to think it’s a woman. As in
http://www.shamusyoung.com/twentysidedtale/?p=951 (“Overly Requited Love”)
I wonder how many of the authors of the vehement anti-chainmail bikini posts would be equally disparaging of the loin-cloth and capes the Spartans in 300 wore? (As opposed to their nice shiny almost Iron-age armor.)
I think that the reason most NPCs are male is because most GMs and game designers are male.
When I design a character, I always remember a question that Chris Claremont used to pose to himself.
“Why isn’t (the character) a woman?”
Those last two panels with Gimli and Legolas were perfect–they were what made this comic for me.
“I’m just glad he’s picking on someone else for a change.” I laughed out loud. The facial expressions are perfect.
omg the WTF look on theoden’s face in panel 8 is priceless!! u rock!
This is also one of my favourites, well done Shamus..
Chainmail bikini, ring of warmth, bracers of armour.
Just because she’s pretty doesn’t mean she has to be stupid!
Heh, now that’s a nifty trick.
“Here’s my character portrait.”
“She’s got bracers of armor and a ring of warmth. She’s a wizard.”
I’m not so much defending the image as deriding the criticism itself, which is extremely one-sided. In fact, you might say it’s sexist.
There’s also the image of the hulking barbarian with the fur loin cloth in a tundra, but few people seem to complain about that, ignoring the fact that in reality they had layers of skins and decent armor, in favour of oiled pecs and eight-packs. I think it’s because the guys don’t mind – it’s “macho”.
As a woman who wear chainmail bikinis allow me to add a few points.
1) my top is NOT lined and doesn’t need to be, the weave is thick and tight so no seeing through and no pinchin because it’s woven in a pyramid shape and so folds away from the skin.
2) It’s aluminum so it doesn’t get hot or cold, it stays at body temp. (It is a bit chilly first thing in the morning, though)
3) I don’t do it because I’m, “These are the same kinds of women who take their lives in their hands dancing in four inch spike heels because they attract guys. They're the same kinds of women who corsetted themselves down to 15 inches in the 19th century, or had their floating ribs surgically removed in the very early 20th (back when anesthetics sucked, remember, and surgical patients still had a decent chance of dying of infection). You'll always find a minority who are willing to put up with pain, discomfort and even mutilation for the sake of being “attractive.”” I do it because I actually like my body and don’t always feel a need to hide to hide it. I eat well, work hard, and hate high heels. If I could get away with it I’d wear it more often, not less. It’s comfy, frankly.
4)I was already engaged when I started to wear the chainmail, and am now married and still like the mail.
5) It has no armor value at all. Which is why none of my characters would ever wear it in game.
Just some thoughts.
dillochan brings up a point I’d been avoiding vocalizing, as I’m a guy…
If you’ve got it, flaunt it. My friends and I regularly hit the gym – I’ve yet to see a guy who’s got the body avoid wearing tight clothing. My other group of friends (all overweight, some grossly) all tend to wear loose t-shirts and the like, while my gym friends enjoy showing off their six-packs. (Personally I’m not over weight but I don’t have abs, so I wear tight shirts but won’t take’em off…)
Now, keeping in mind we’re not really dealing with /practicality/ here, as I doubt anyone thinks a chain mail bikini is protective, but if it was possible, my friends probably would wander about in loin-clothes at ren faires carrying big ass weapons – ’cause they CAN, and they know they look good doing so. And I’ve always assumed that about the people who dress up, be it chain mail bikinis or 6 inch heels – they do it because they can carry it off.
I confess, when people complain, I tend to become very curious as to their own build.
Long time lurker – great reading!!!!
“Here's my character portrait.”
“She's got bracers of armor and a ring of warmth. She's a wizard.”
I actually had a character that did this – my mage got her hands on a chain mail bikini, that was deamed to be of such little practical armor usage that it did not hinder her spell casting at all, but was enchanted for warmth & armor. Wore it with a nice white fur cloak and boots. Loved it!!! (& the player is also female)
And we thought the dwarven females were hard to spot…
I dunno… I think Aragorn must be a leg man, otherwise I think he’d have realized by now that Legolas and Haldir don’t have breasts.
Then again, he ain’t too bright…
“bwa-ha-ha! You've gotta admit that Haldir does look an awful lot like Jan Brady.”
My gosh, you’re right! I can’t wait to go watch it again just so I can imagine him saying, “Marsha, Marsha, Marsha!”
I would just like to take this moment, on behalf of all men everywhere, to thank the chain mail bikini wearing women out there for the joy you’ve given us. Just don’t forget the power you weld. Just imagine the conversations overheard in Troy, Camelot , & countless other places throughout history that sounded like this: “Look ’round you,man, at all the dead. All because you had to lie with a beautiful woman. Well? Was it worth it?” “Yes; yes it was…”
Yeah power to women in chainmail bikini’s
Its not sexism, its just the way it has to be. The men do all the fighting while the women wait in thier beds for when the men need to relax.
Why argue? The chainmail bikini is the way it has to be.
As a female fighter (SCA and Dark Ages reenactment groups) myself, with my own set of riveted chain mail, thank you very much, let me state that unless you’ve been HIT in chain mail, with a weapon, you ain’t a woman in armor.
Scarlet Knight Says:
Despite all the chain mail bikinis seen at the Ren Faire & in spite of all my encouragement (ie pleading), my wife still won't wear one…unless (she claims) I develop the body that allows me to wear the barbarian loin-cloth…
I say I have the body of a god, and my wife agrees. Of course, I am talking “mighty-thewed, pointy-helmeted Norse” type and she has “Squamous Nightmare from Beyond The Veil Of Time” in mind.
[Armour, clothing etc] Why on earth would any female adventurer wear a skirt of any length? Scotsmen notwithstanding, if your civilization has mastered the secret of the trouser leg, tough pants would seem to be a better choice all-round. Nothing spells embarrasment like a snake up the kilt in mid-combat.
Cutaway armour of any type looks sensational on a woman, especially a young woman in good physical shape, but is hardly practical when mixing it up with non-humans (who probably won’t get distratced by the real-estate) in snake-infested grasslands or scorpion-riddled caves.
However, at SCA events, Renfaires and so forth, if you are young enough to carry it off, the rule to live by is “if you’ve got it, flaunt it”. You’re only young once and it wears off really fast.
[Corsets and Rib Extraction Surgery] I’ve been hearing this story since I was a kid, and I have begun to question it of late. Rib removal is nowhere near as simple as it sounds, and there are enough places on the web that one can see radical body mods using a corset sans the need for chloroform and the knife that I now view this story with extreme skepicism.
It is far more likely that someone once saw a picture of a radically reduced Victorian waist or two and assumed it couldn’t be done any other way. Once that person had suggested the rib removal scenario to someone else the story would take off. It sounds reasonable on the face of it. Think “McDonalds Wormburger Legend”. But I haven’t found a reliable account of it being done or of anyone dying from such surgery in Victorian times – when they did have anaestheics but surgeons didn’t follow rigorous hygene at all times.
I am ready to be shown evidence though. I am a man of science and trained to view young women wearing squeaky-tight corsets with medical detachment. Grunt grunt.
I’ve seen an article by a forensic archeologist which pictures of deformed ribcages of corseted-wearers of that time period. Believe it. Their ribcages didn’t flare, they formed an oval. No wonder they were prone to fainting.
my group uses dice to decide gender
for everybody in the gaming world, unless for some reason they have to be of a perticular gender(such as a drow leader)
I allways loved Inphyy from Ninety Nine Night’s armour – a mixture of plate, over breeches (and possibly other stuff) covered her entire body. Sans head and cleavage. So it was great!
Unless someone tried to stab her in the chest or face…
Also, first post from me! Great stuff Shamus.
Wow, Patrick… I mean seriously… Wow.
That has got to be the worst thing I’ve ever heard: You think that arguing against sexism in a medium is a small topic? It’s huge! In fact, it’s called ‘Feminism’. There’s something horribly misogynystic everywhere, especially in comics, video games, and other ‘geeky’ subculture.
And even though it’s a subculture it’s still a big deal, especially because of how many girls are starting to get into said mediums (not like it was ok beforehand either).
Patrick, the girls aren’t here to dance for you in chainmail bikinis, small leather outfits, and what have you. They want to kill dragons too.
It serves Legolas’ player right for putting points in Charisma. That’s no way to power play it should be a dump stat. And NPCs with Charisma are obviously no good in a fight!
As an addendum to my previous post: This goes for George too.
How is it NOT sexist to say what you just did?
You should be ashamed.
Perhaps being an English major, a shoe salesman and a hardcore grognard didn't earn Gary a lot of popularity with the ladies, and he was a tad bitter?
Both of Gary’s wives were very attractive, as was his daughter. I don’t think Gary ever had any problem being popular with the ladies.
I wonder how many of the authors of the vehement anti-chainmail bikini posts would be equally disparaging of the loin-cloth and capes the Spartans in 300 wore?
Hmm, in battle the Greeks generally dropped the loin cloths to avoid soiling them, and often did not wear them otherwise (the Persians had a lot to say about the fact that the Greeks did not have tailored clothing, just short cloaks that did not cover them much). Guess 300 has to put some more clothes on them, but the actual Greeks wore less clothing, not more.
As for the first official AD&D figures designed at TSR, all the females are covered up.
in battle, the Greeks wore armor. Because it protects your organs better than not wearing armor. They weren’t stupid.
Yes, they just exercised and competed nekkid.
This is pretty funny-as an engaged fem. gamer, my fiancee’ has helped me amass a tiny collection of 15 or so “bad-ass female minis”. I’ve got swashbuckler girls, angel girls, rangers, and rogues. As long as I don’t buy barbarians, I don’t have a difficult time finding fully (and fashionably) dressed femme fatales. I keep them in one of those “caboodle” cosmetic cases that has fold out hinge drawers. The fiancee’s thinks it’s funny that men approach D&D like little boys what with the action figures and all, and I’m approaching it like a little girl, apparently.
As an artist, I’ve had to study the use of women as models in art, and the chain mail bikini is kind of a product of the “woman as object to look at”. I see it as irritating, but mostly harmless. I must say that I spent over a year in a game where half the party referred to my elf sorcerer with CHA 18 as a prostitute at every given opportunity. I should have left months earlier or mentioned something, because this was so pervasive that I was abjectly miserable. So sometimes there’s a dark side to the harmlessness.
So weird that this comic’s comments have devolved into a discussion of feminism and chain-mail.
*Getting back to the comic* Actually I think it’s realistic that someone would have trouble discerning the sex of another species, even a humanoid one.
adam’s right, there.
I’ve been forced to read through a heck of a lot of (translated) the old Greek literature, and they seem to talk a heck of a lot about their weapons. (Homer, Euripides, Aeschylus… Taking a random Classics course.)
Book 18 of the Iliad is the arming of Achilles, and while almost all of it is about his shield, it does take pains to point out the breastplate, helmet, and leg armor.
Historically, they indeed had body armor (be it just a breastplate), a helmet, and leg armor.
Now, while it’s entirely possible they didn’t wear clothes, I doubt quite a bit that they would have their bits hanging out in the middle of war where it may be nicked by a stray blow, or even nicked by kicked up ground.
A simple search on ‘hoplite’ is very illuminating. Consider the description of a hoplite costume here:
“He is bearded and dressed in hoplite costume–with a short chiton, cuirass, helmet, and greaves, holds his right hand at his side, and holds a spear upright with his upraised left hand.”
And if you don’t know what a chiton is (I didn’t): http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chiton_(costume)
“On the right two hoplites clasp hands in a gesture of farewell. Each wears a short chiton, a short mantle pinned on the shoulders and pushed back, and a pilos helmet.”
You’d have to have backing, otherwise armor would chafe. And you’d have to have armor (in war), otherwise you’re an idiot, and very soon to be deceased. Consequently, there’s little reason to deliberately wear a super-short chiton to flash the enemy, unless you want to give them an extra, obvious, place to hit you.
82 Rebecca Says:
March 27th, 2007 at 11:28 pm
So weird that this comic's comments have devolved into a discussion of feminism and chain-mail.
*Getting back to the comic* Actually I think it's realistic that someone would have trouble discerning the sex of another species, even a humanoid one.
remember, his player can only hear the description which happens to be “yellow-haired and fair”. Common description for a woman. That and he’s a bit of a dummy.
*Also getting back to the comic*
I always hated Peter Jackson’s hippie stoner elves. (I could stand Legolas because his impossible feats and competing with Gimli in battle pretty much were book-accurate.) They in no way resembled the elves that Tolkien described, who were badass and majestic.
Thus, I am enjoying the ‘heh heh, the elf’s a girl’ ribbing that’s going on here.
I know I’m way late to the gate on this one, and this was published six years ago, but anyway, that’s my two cents.
And bravo, Shamus, sir. May your site stay viral forever.
I must remember to read this comic more frequently! It’s always good, but I nearly woke Sam up while reading this episode.
Someone actually emailed me to let me know that there was a post in this thread linking to an article on my site, but that the URL needed to be corrected. Well, if it was here, it’s been deleted, or maybe it’s just that I’m up way, way past my bedtime. The only articles I can imagine anyone having linked to, though, would be Confessions of a Girlfriend Gamer or Living the Dream. Both articles are WAY out of date, and contain some of the same material, as they were written for different purposes. But there they are, FWIW.
Now that I’m not a new gamer any more, I will say that my fantasy game characters haven’t ever worn any chain mail bikinis. They don’t wear armor in general – just bracers of armor, and why not? – and they dress appropriately for whatever they’re doing. They show more or less skin depending on their intent and the situation.
We (my partner, Sam, runs most of the games I play in) play with more women than men, partly because men frequently seem surprised by female PCs and NPCs who act like real people rather than caricatures. They’re fine with making sexual jokes, but if characters actually have sex (off-scene, thank you), they’re really uncomfortable. And if a PC uses her body to achieve a goal? (Say, she distracts a guard, or tempts a target into a private place to make it easier to kill him.) That’s all she’s good for from then on. They essentially consider her a prostitute.
Happily, other female players seldom have those kinds of hangups – or, at least, we’ve been very fortunate in finding wonderful women with whom to game.
Recently we’ve been playing the Serenity RPG with the After Serenity folks – even though it is a mostly male group ;-) The game sessions are recorded and put out on their podcast feed. It’s quite different from the fantasy RPGs to which I’m more accustomed, but it’s a good group, David’s a very flexible GM, and I adore Firefly.
Why would you think (A)D&D is almost exclusively North-American? I’ll have you know that it is quite prevalent in the UK, in Germany and probably everywhere else in Europe as well … And from an academic point of view – writing about RPGS and subcultures is a valid academic interest, there is a multitude of topics out there that are less interesting and concern fewer people than RPGs do. Writing about (sub)cultures and communities that attract hundreds of thousands, sell for more every year (think WoW, think WotC, think LOtR) makes absolutely sense.
Okay, so it is early in the morning and I’m not fully awake … as for females in roleplaying, in both of my groups (AD&D, Cthulhu) the female players are in the majority.
And I’d choose equipment with higher armor over equipment with higher *charisma* any day, thank you very much. *grins*
This is stuff iÂ´d found some years ago.
The chain mail bikini is actually a +5 armor bolstered with a powerfull protection from element enchantment
“Both of Gary's wives were very attractive, as was his daughter. I don't think Gary ever had any problem being popular with the ladies.”
Are you saying he was popular with his daughter? That’s a whole new kind of creepy.
In Cthulhu I find my self playing a surprising number of catholic priests. I just think they fit the mood of the game. Plus I am rather insane and like having a character who can read those books that make you crazy. The last one I played tried preforming exorcism rituals on the evil things because he was convinced they were possessed. This, of course, had no effect.
The party I DM for consists of 4 female players and 3 male players, each playing their RealLifeâ„¢ gender. All of us enjoy our local ren faire and two of the ladies are *very* attractive and are quite fond of the corset look (it also brings more customers into the faerie and art shops they run respectively). I’d also like to add that one of those two is a far better shot with a bow than I and her skills in Kendo and Western fencing are not to be ignored…
As for their characters, everyone (male and female) is garbed practically but that’s not to say the ladies object to the Valkyrie or bellydancer. In fact, they rather like the idea of being able to “flaunt it” as well as kick ass and have found various means to do so. For one, I’m kind of surprised that no one has mentioned the Glamered Armor enchantment ( http://www.d20srd.org/srd/magicItems/magicArmor.htm#glamered ) which allows Your protective gear to essential look like clothing. I’m not one to get fussy over what the constitutes “normal clothing” so when the female warlock’s female player says her glamered elven chain looks like bellydance attire I don’t see that any rule say it can’t.
The pixie warmage and elven bard (also female) are quite happy with celestial chain (which can be worn without notice under clothing). Lastly, taking advantage of my regional armor rules, the cleric wears a short custom-fitted breastplate over a long mithril-chain hauberk. In general, the physical allure of the characters seems to be in direct proportion (no pun intended) to that of the lady playing them. Perhaps it’s a comfort-zone sort of thing but no-one has taken issue with it and as the ladies’ AC scores will testify, they head into battle looking good AND being well-protected. (Their ACs are actually better than the guys’ who are all melee types.)
Side-note: The female cleric’s player was excited that I’m allowing spells from the Book of Exalted Deeds as this will give her character the freedom to wear a dress (the player studies ballet) and yet have the equivalent of full-plate armor (see Greater Luminous Armor). Shiny-good never looked so good…
BTW, as a long-time reader, 1st-time poster, I must say that I find the comments by other veteran player just as interesting as the excellent comic Shamus puts together.
And I'd choose equipment with higher armor over equipment with higher *charisma* any day, thank you very much. *grins*
Unless you’re a Paladin, where equip with Charisma serves to make you harder to hurt with those nasty, nasty special effects…That’d be an interesting scene. Paladin looking over their gear: Hmmm…do I go with the protection or the Cha boosting this time?
Of course, if you can get both, you’re laughing.
WRT Charisma vs. Protection: In my setting Charisma not only represents force of personality but also Divine Grace/Favor (i.e. it’s not *directly* related to how pretty they are). To represent the favor of the gods, Charisma is applied as a Divine bonus to AC whenever an enemy attempts to confirm a Critical Threat.
“Luck often enough will save a man, if his courage holds” “”Buliwyf, The 13th Warrior
Suddenly the players don’t see Charisma as a dump stat and it leads to them taking their heroic parts (and alignment) more seriously “” they don’t want to lose their gift of Grace.
Mind You, this has *nothing* to do with chainmail bikinis, just pointing out a more classical take on “Charisma” as opposed to the colloquialism used by most gamers. :)
Stephen M (Ethesis) Says:
I don't think Gary ever had any problem being popular with the ladies.
But as we more mature gamers know, the trick is to stay popular with them.
Otherwise they decamp and take all your good stuff with them.
Both of Gary's wives were very attractive, as was his daughter. I don't think Gary ever had any problem being popular with the ladies.
WHY did you mention his DAUGHTER here?
Well, it’s not HIS daughter! :P
Now, I wouldn’t go and say the chainmail bikini outfit is *completely* useless. What if they were fighting someone obsessively fixated on attacking their breasts and crotch?
Maybe some *very* specific spots on their waist and back.
Why would you want to leave your highly vulnerable abdominal region uncovered? I’m thinking in practical terms. I guess you could cast some kind of magical forcefield spell around yourself and then armor wouldn’t matter.
Why don’t the men in these things ever stride around oily and barechested as catnip for the ladies? Just askin’…as a female…
Also, this comic has gotten me wanting to learn to play D&D. Unfortunately, my impression is that it is like bridge: unwelcoming and unforgiving of noobs.
You have heard of Conan, right? The barechested barbarian is probably just as widespread as the chainmail bikini, it’s just that nobody whines about it. (And I get that the whiners about the bikinis are a small minority. Not trying to suggest otherwise, just noting they exist)
Funny… but creepy. Mind if I post spam?
Spam, spam, lovely spam, wonderful spam…
A hundred comments! Everybody wins!
So that’s what it says when you reach 100…
101? OVER A HUNDRED COMMENTS? What are you people talking about?
Alas, curiosity has gotten the better of me.
Okay, you can delete these posts now. Curiosity satisfied.
Note to self: do NOT, under any circumstances, read this at 2:00am, for fear of waking the household from outbursts of laughter. (I about DIED when I saw Haldir’s face in frame 7!)
Didn’t I read some time ago, that there were no d100 images, that there would be an apparent endless addition of d20?
This one was great. I love how Shamus seems to have mastered the ‘pregnant pause’, when his NPC’s are dumbfounded by player idiocy.
I can almost hear the crickets chirping in the background of panel 7, while Haldir stands there gaping.
*chirp* *chirp* *chirp*
Really, what do you say to something like that?
w00t! Comment 106!
Love this stuff. Shame you had to stop. Ever considered parodying another genre by means of an rpg campaign?
A couple of misspellings I found (too late at comment 107, I fear): In frame 4, it is “seize”, not “sieze”. In frame 6, I believe you wanted “ourselves”, not “outselves”.
Poor Aragorn…he tries so hard…and yet, unfortunately for him, he most always seems to mistake elven men for gorgeous women. I feel sorry for Haldir, too…you can almost read his mind in the 7th panel…
I was almost as confused as he was when Aragorn said “she” – and when I got it, I was also in a state of utter bewilderemnt…
1. “Bikini = babe. Covered = guy
While it's a generalization, that's an unfortunate truth. You'll have to remember that a majority of RPG fandom is male. And sex sells. Female personas have to look good to be memorable. The chainmail bikini helps.
Generally, female fantasy costumes of that nature have no true function. They don't protect against the elements. It's not comfortable – scale and chainmail can pinch the skin and snag hair unless there's cloth padding (or the female shaves certain… areas). They provide no armor value whatsoever (exposed thighs and abdomens being a favorite theme for females).
It's there to make the male gawk and go “Yep. That's a babe.”
Despite my preachings of course, I am a guy, and while I believe that such attire is non-functional, I will also be the first to admit that it IS nice to look at.”
I laugh at how much men take notice of the female anatomy. It’s almost like our purpose in life is to satisfy the sexual cravings of men. This scares me.
2. “Hah, there's a reason that the optional skill “elven gender identification” was such a long-running gag in our various campaigns…
And in some cases I think even I needed it while watching LotRs, and probably failed a few checks. And I'm a girl with an eye for the pretty-boy elven type.
Very true!! Except I was more on the lookout for hot rangers…
Me (in Arwen’s voice): What’s this? A ranger caught off his guard?
3. Gotta love Aragon stairing at Haldir's chest… “There once was an allianc… HEY! My eyes are up here!””
BWAHAHAHA…I never really noticed that until you pointed it out!!
4. “The look of open lust in Aragorn's eyes is truly disturbing… I'm never going to watch those movies in the same way.
Thanks, Shamus! ”
Ugh…somehow I wish you hadn’t said that…now I’m gunna be thinking along the lines of Shamus when I watch the movies! Open lust…*shakes head*
Oh man, I think I just woke up my wife with laughter on this one. Thanks!
Very hard to read this at work… they keep asking what I am giggling about.
I’m experimenting with a character from a race like elves, but ‘more evolved’ for a story I’m writing, whom almost everyone mistakes for a woman. No, it’s not a cheesy humor fan book. But I think it can lead to some tension-relieving situations. He’s not my fall-back character relief guy or anything, but I think at least once or twice it should finally be funny. I love it when high, fair races are mistaken for women. I don’t know why.
Wow… I’m litteraly rolling on the floor laughing. Best one yet
Aragorn, it’s time to admit it… you have a problem.
Honestly, to me, it seemed like Haldir was the only elf who actually looked male.
At least he doesn’t look stoned like Galadriel or seem about to say stern things to Mr. Anderson.
HAHA this whole series is hilarious. it doesn’t get old!
dude, i laugh my @$$ off every time when its apparent that Aragorn thinks ALL elves are female.
Is it just me, or does Legolas look like he’s about to kiss that arrow, or something?
Maybe it’s just me being half-asleep…
Anyway, I’m re-rereading this, and it’s making me laugh as much as ever. Great job!
I have never accepted such stereotypes. I always roll odd/even for the sex of each npc i create and they all wear appropriate outfits based on their function, their funding, and the current conditions. And i always stop my players whenever they automatically assume the sex of a newcomer before i’ve told them.
Holy crap mate, i nearly wet myself on this one….the creepy way he kept moving forward with his “eye on the prize”
Awesome, laughed at others but this one wins….so far
If Aragorn was this stupid in the movies, I might not have hated him so much.
I want to see the expression on a guy’s face when I call him a “smoldering temptress.” XD lol!
rolf. though he has a point. most elves look like girls.
Only Peter Jackson’s movie elves!
I am stiil surprissed that they remember the bad guys name.
Watching the film, I did wonder how so many Elves got past an army of ten thousand Uruks who were blocking the approach to Helm’s Deep, completely unseen and undetected. Nor did they give into the primal urge to take a pop at the Orcs there and then….
…far better to have stayed with Tolkein’s original concept of a hundred or so Rangers led by only two half-elven princes, who in any case did not catch up with him till after Helm’s Deep… I read the book a long time before seeing the film, so my LotR is the written text, and every deviation from this made me wince – even the ones that worked better on screen….
Thanks for joining the discussion. Be nice, don't post angry, and enjoy yourself. This is supposed to be fun. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked*
You can enclose spoilers in <strike> tags like so:
<strike>Darth Vader is Luke's father!</strike>
You can make things italics like this:
Can you imagine having Darth Vader as your <i>father</i>?
You can make things bold like this:
I'm <b>very</b> glad Darth Vader isn't my father.
You can make links like this:
I'm reading about <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Darth_Vader">Darth Vader</a> on Wikipedia!
You can quote someone like this:
Darth Vader said <blockquote>Luke, I am your father.</blockquote>