The Plot-Driven Door

By Shamus Posted Monday Feb 12, 2007

Filed under: Game Design 62 comments

Some readers have noted my obsessive, even Kahn-like vendetta against Neverwinter Nights 2. During my brief moments of lucidity I have come to realize that the game has driven me quite mad, and that I am likely to go on ranting about it for some time. I’m comfortable in this madness, although out of affection for the many fine people who visit this site I do suggest you back slowly away from this post before I even get started. However, if you have appetite for a tirade, then perhaps the following will slake your inexplicable craving…

Most videogames in the RPG genre have plot-driven doors. You know, a locked door which may be made of wood and 100 years old, but which is indestructable, un-pickable, and un-openable until some plotpoint takes place. Some games are better about this than others, but it’s a necessity of the medium.

Players tolerate plot-doors to different degrees, mostly depending on the strength of the writing. Some games are really eager to abuse this, and use plot-doors in lieu of coherent writing. Let me bring up the most foul example of a plot-driven door. This one:

The plot-driven door.

Let me tell you about this door…
Continue reading ⟩⟩ “The Plot-Driven Door”

 


 

Cheat Codes

By Shamus Posted Monday Feb 12, 2007

Filed under: Game Design 26 comments

Here is something that I’ve noticed:

The availability of useful cheat codes in any given game is inversely proportional to the likelihood that you will need them.

A game which has clear objectives and allows the player to explore the gameworld freely and save anytime they like is going to have lots of cheat codes. These cheat codes range from bestowing a preposterously large arsenal to the simple yet effective “god mode” – the videogame trump card which renders all enemy arguments mute.

A game that gives you vague objectives that can only be fully understood by making repeated attempts, which makes the player race against the clock, or which forbids saving except at select intervals, this will have no cheats to aid the player in overcoming or bypassing the inherent frustrations of the game. If there are cheat codes, they will be for things like giving your character a humorously large head, or making them wear a funny hat.

I don’t know why this is. The more DIAS the game is, the more likely that there will be no cheat codes. Console games are by far the worst offenders, although guilty parties can be found on both sides of the PC / Console divide. I’ve played many games which were brutal, unforgiving, and which offered the frustrated player no recourse but to surrender hours of their time playing the same scene over and over again until they meet with the game’s exacting standards. They can either slave away in this state of non-entertainment, or they can give up and leave the remainder of the game unplayed.

The ESRB is so eager to let me know if the game will torment my ears with bad words, or if my eyes might be scalded by the sight of boobies, but they never tell me what I really want to know: They never warn me that I need to pick up an extra controller or mouse while I’m buying the game, to replace the one I’m inevitably going to smash.

ESRB Timesink warning label.

 


 

DM of the Rings: Only 2 This Week

By Shamus Posted Sunday Feb 11, 2007

Filed under: Notices 15 comments

I only made 2 strips this weekend. However, I hasten to add that both strips are quite hefty. One is double size, and the other is the very first triple-sized strip. To preserve the symmetry mandated by the obsessive-compulsive disorder I’m cultivating, I’ll post them on Tues & Thurs this week.

Every weekend I sit down on Saturday morning and think, “This is it. I really am out of ideas this time. I’ll never think of anything good.” I’ll then cobble together some strips, and wince. Are these funny? Am I losing it? Then I’ll post them, lots of people will like them, and at least one person will say they have a new favorite. None of this prevents me from going through the same thing the next Saturday.

I wonder if other webcomic authors go through this?

 


 

DM of the Rings LXII:
Everything But the Girl

By Shamus Posted Friday Feb 9, 2007

Filed under: DM of the Rings 50 comments

Gimli, Legolas, and Aragorn in Rohan.  Eowyn as quest reward.

“Plot” is what the DM does to amuse himself when the players aren’t talking.

 


 

Mass Effect

By Shamus Posted Friday Feb 9, 2007

Filed under: Game Reviews 28 comments

mass_effect.jpg
I’m reading up on Mass Effect, a game which is being produced by Bioware and has every indication of being exqusite. The game follows the time-honored tradition of giving you a spaceship and a crew, and letting you use these resources to save the galaxy. I’ve been saving the galaxy since Starflight in the late 8o’s, and I can tell you that galaxy-saving just doesn’t get old. It’s XBox 360-only, but if previous trends continue then the game will end up on the PC within the next couple of years.

However, if other previous trends continue, then in three years Obsidian will come out with Mass Effect 2, a game which will trap you on a spaceship with a crew of dysfunctional morons and sociopaths who all hate you yet still call you their captain for no discernable reason. The gameplay will consist of navigating dialog trees which insult or infuriate you in various ways, for sixty hours, until your ship at last crashes into the sun and the game ends.

 


 

A Plague of Links

By Shamus Posted Thursday Feb 8, 2007

Filed under: Links 9 comments

Since yesterday, I’ve seen links appear from The Rodent’s Burrow, Rodent Household, The Magic Rat, and Larry the Lab Rat. Strange.

Now I forget: Are badgers and ferrets considered rodents?

At any rate, I’m glad this blog is so popular among our rodent friends. Next up, I’m planning an ad campaign to increase readership among waterfowl, which has been lacking.

Also, the above-linked Rodent’s Burrow has “My dice are trying to kill me!” t-shirts. Nifty.

 


 

Ringtone Verboten

By Shamus Posted Thursday Feb 8, 2007

Filed under: Rants 26 comments

I’m not impressed with htAkismet. I see no effect in the number of spam comments that hit this site. Maybe it hasn’t started to do its thing yet. I really wish it had some kind of “here is how I work and here are the IPs I’ve banned” control panel.

At any rate, I just got 600 spams in a three hour stretch, two-thirds of which were for “ringtones”. We all have different tolerances for this sort of business, but this is more or less my personal limit. I have added “ringtones” to my list of forbidden words, which is my orbital death-ray solution. Note that if you drop that word into a comment the system will eat it without even telling me. I’ll never see it. I suggest humans switch to using the term “ringsongs”, or perhaps, “crap nobody wants like, ever, man.” Either one. It’s a trade-off between brevity and accuracy, really.

And let me just add that I see ringtones as one of the sleaziest, most lothesome scams to emerge from the mobile phone revolution, which is really saying something. The average cell phone bill is an incomprehensible ten-page morass of gibberish and nonsense leading up to the “Ammount Due” on the last page, a number which is clearly generated using the Mersenne Twister. I’m careful to never read the fine print of my bill aloud, lest I summon some slime-covered demon from the lower planes. Despite this danger, I have to give them credit for actually selling something people want in the midst of bewildering and then subsequently screwing them.

This is not the case with ringtones. I’ve always thought that the $1 per song on iTunes was excessive. That’s about the same ammount I would pay for a song on CD, except the CD version comes with – you know – a CD, as well as album art, lyrics, and a nice jewel case to protect these treasures. I can play it anywhere without having to ask Steve Jobs first and without needing to infect my computer with “install” iTunes. But ringtones take this ridiculous transaction and turn it into something far more absurd. Song rental.

The ringtones on my phone aren’t $1, they’re $3. You’re not just limited to listening to them on your iPod, you’re limited to listening to them on your phone. When someone calls. You aren’t getting a song, you’re getting part of a song. Oh yeah… you’re not buying it, you’re renting it for 90 days. This is like charging someone twenty dollars for a half-eaten hamburger.

The “free” ringtones, I’m sure, represent something even more horrible. There must be a reason spammers want to get people to download them. I can only guess, but I’m betting this is a way to get a user’s phone number and a way to circumvent the “do not call” list. Hey! We have an existing prior established ongoing and totally legit business relationship with this guy. He downloaded a ringtone from us! That deal is a lot worse than renting part of a song for $3.

What? I’ve gone off-topic? Twice? In each paragraph? Sorry. Where was I? Oh right:

Don’t use the word “ringtones” in comments.

UPDATE: This sucks. Akismet apparently does its thing BEFORE checking for forbidden words, which, in effect, removes that feature from WordPress. So annoyed.