Lord of the Rings Online #5: Shadow and Flame

By Shamus
on Mar 27, 2016
Filed under:
Shamus Plays

This is it. It’s time for the brigands to attack the town of Archet. No matter who wins, I have to say they’ve been very sporting to wait this long.

As I mentioned before, we’re still in the tutorial of the game. The Archet we’ve been in is a kind of playpen newbie zone that you can’t leave. It’s also set to perma-daylight, since these events were all supposed to take place in a single day.

During the attack we’ll be in a special instance version of the town, so there won’t be any other players around. (Not that there are all that many in the newbie zone anyway.)

Jon Brackenbrook decides that we should wait at the lodge until nightfall. I don’t know why. The lodge is not in town, and we’re supposed to defend the town. I suspect he wants to secure the lodge until the last of the stew is gone, but I don’t say that out loud.

Night arrives, and I find myself on a hill with Jon.

Hey, weren`t there like, five other strong, healthy, well-armed guys stuffing themselves at the lodge? How come you`re the only one to show up?

Hey, weren`t there like, five other strong, healthy, well-armed guys stuffing themselves at the lodge? How come you`re the only one to show up?

He sends me into town on my own, promising to find “another way in” himself. Except, there are only two ways into town: The south gate and the east gate. He’s sending me in on the eastern side.

Even if you weren`t a brigand, I`d probably kill you just for wearing that outfit. I`ve seen vagrants more debonair than you.

Even if you weren`t a brigand, I`d probably kill you just for wearing that outfit. I`ve seen vagrants more debonair than you.

I run down the hill and start hacking down the invading brigands. I was never very crazy about killing people, but I guess I’m used to it now. Yesterday I killed a man for a pair of fur-lined pumps with a low heel. (In green.) Later I killed half a dozen people for a wide-brimmed cavalier hat with an ostrich plume and a satin band. Very stylish. Now I’m killing people with no promise of garments at all. It’s tragic that it’s come to this.

I’d kill to get my hands on something with cuffed sleeves.

What do you call a female brigand? Brigandette?

What do you call a female brigand? Brigandette?

There’s something that’s been bothering my about Jon’s plan. Well, a lot of things, really. Now that I think of it, I guess it’s everything about his plan seems a little off. But the detail bugging me right now is the bit about the east road. Isn’t this the road with…

The top 8 reasons I hate fighting spiders are... everything. Everything is my top 8 reasons.

The top 8 reasons I hate fighting spiders are... everything. Everything is my top 8 reasons.

Bloody hell.

The east road is the one infested with spiders the size of donkeys.

Have you seen enough screenshots of me fighting spiders by this point? Maybe a little yes? Ok good. Let’s just skip the dozen or so images of my little Hobbit stabbing spiders and move on…

The last spider falls and I arrive at the gates of the city.

Better late than never. Er, unless you lived in this burning town. Then both outcomes are about the same.

Better late than never. Er, unless you lived in this burning town. Then both outcomes are about the same.

This is it. The big showdown. I go over Jon’s battle plans one last time to make sure I’m not missing anything:

1) Stay at the lodge – far outside of the fortifications, where we will not be able to influence the battle in any way.
2) Wait until nightfall.
3) Wait some more, until long after the battle has begun.
4) Split into two groups. Of one person each.
5) Assault the town separately. I will fight directly through the spider nest (again) while Jon will hike all the way around the mountain and arrive sometime after bandits have destroyed the town, rebuilt it, moved in, and raised a new generation of bandit children.
6) That’s pretty much it. No plans for what we’re supposed to do once we get to town. Although I’m sure I can stab bandits without worrying that I might be going off-mission.

In town, it seems Calder Cob has escaped from jail and is now beating on the jailer.

Was the pie really THAT bad, Cob?

Was the pie really THAT bad, Cob?

You remember Ned the jailer. Earlier he had me picking berries, because he wanted to “interrogate” Cob by feeding him. Nobody bothered to execute Cob after he finished (not) talking on account of the cake they fed him, and now his brigand buddies have set him loose.

I`m going to guess he`s probably not appreciating your boot.

I`m going to guess he`s probably not appreciating your boot.

I guess he didn’t like the cake. Well, I’ve been waiting all day for the chance to do this…

Oh no. They burned down the town`s entire supply of nondescript crates!

Oh no. They burned down the town`s entire supply of nondescript crates!

Taste justice you greasy pantaloon-wearing clodpole!

It`s an MMO quest, so I`ll probably have to kill a dozen Calder Cobs and collect their Cob-pelts.

It`s an MMO quest, so I`ll probably have to kill a dozen Calder Cobs and collect their Cob-pelts.

/spit

Looks like Ned isn’t the picture of vibrancy and health. I’m not a physician, but I’m pretty sure he’s suffering from a bad case of Just About To Die.

You`re cold? I could drag you over the the crate fire if you like.

You`re cold? I could drag you over the the crate fire if you like.

Aw. Poor Ned the Jailer. Did that mean old Cob stab your guts out? What a rascal.

MAYBE I SHOULD GET YOU SOME BILBERRIES SO YOU CAN BAKE HIM ANOTHER CAKE!

With his dying breath, Ned tells me to find Amdir. He also warns me the EOGAN is here.

Erm. Who?

Eogan seems to be the second-in-command of this branch of Team Bad Guy. He reports directly to the Nazgul. The brigands have been mentioning him now and again since the opening of the game.

Lulzy hasn’t been paying attention, but if you keep an eye on the dialog you should know who he is by this point in the game. This is his big reveal.

Eogan serves an important purpose. Since this is Lord of the Rings, and since the War of the Ring is going on in the background, the game needs to provide you with important villains and foes that you can actually fight and kill without conflicting with the existing story.

At the same time, Eogan really sticks out as an obvious add-on character. His dialog is overwrought villainous hyperbole, much more suited to City of Heroes than Lord of the Freaking Rings.

Amdir. I’d nearly forgotten about him. The one responsible for me getting stuck defending this nest of cake-baking goofs.

I like how he`s still in the same position, like the whole battle happened and everyone just ignored him.

I like how he`s still in the same position, like the whole battle happened and everyone just ignored him.

“So… hello again Amdir. How’s it going, then? Dying hard or hardly dying?”

Amdir mumbles some stuff about Eogan. I look, and sure enough Eogan is on the other side of a wall of flames. Celandine Brandybuck and another Hobbit are over there as well.

Why is the fire only burning BETWEEN the wooden building and the unexplained lumber pile?

Why is the fire only burning BETWEEN the wooden building and the unexplained lumber pile?

Eogan appears to be fighting the town oldie himself, Captain Brackenbrook. You remember him. He’s the guy who wouldn’t believe that Calder Cob was a traitor until he saw it written on a piece of paper. He’s fighting Eogan, which means at least Brackenbrook has figured out what side he’s on.

Still, that fight is probably not going to turn out very well for our side. I can’t believe I’m saying this, but I need to get over there and help.

Amdir suggests I draw some water from the nearby well and put out the flames.

This is a little tutorial for the “delivery” mechanic, which becomes available later. Eventually I’ll be able to take on these quests where you have to carry an object for a few minutes to get it from A to B. (Which actually equates to several hours, when measured in “psychological time”, which is a thing I just made up.) They’re generally timed, and if you have to fight or enter water you’ll drop the object and have to go back and start over.

This just demonstrates how that works. I just have to click on the well and carry the water about ten paces to the fire.

You okay buddy?

You okay buddy?

I douse the fire, and suddenly an unbelievable number of things all happen at once.

Crap. Looks like there`s barely anyone left for me to kill.

Crap. Looks like there`s barely anyone left for me to kill.

Okay, try to keep up here:

The fire goes out. Brackenbrook goes down. Amdir gets up. I go in. Eogan gets smug. Amdir takes a knee. I get out my sword. Some brigands end up on the pointy end. Amdir runs off. Celandine goes into a conniption. Eogan gets chatty. I get pissed. We both get ready to rumble. Eogan gets cocky. Then he goes down. The Hobbits get rescued.

Got all that? Yeah. Me neither.

See, Amdir has been losing his mind since getting stabbed. It looks like he finally caved and fell fully under the control of the Nazgul. Once that happened he quit the battle and wandered off. He’s now a thrall of the bad guys.

Then Eogan and I had a showdown, which I won.

Celandine shouts `HOORAY` while standing in a burning city strewn with corpses. She`s really easy to please.

Celandine shouts `HOORAY` while standing in a burning city strewn with corpses. She`s really easy to please.

See?

I turn my attention to the Hobbits. My friend Celandine Brandybuck (yes, we’re friends, we’re just very catty) is here with some simpering toadstool named Mundo Sackville-Baggins. As if I wanted to hear more exposition, Mundo brings me up to speed:

Eogan has been trying to kidnap the Hobbits for days. Apparently he was sent to the Shire with orders to capture someone named “Baggins” and to get his ring. Eogan, being a human, (and thus a magnificent dolt) didn’t think that perhaps there could be more than one person with “Baggins” in their name, so he’s been chasing Mundo around even though Mundo doesn’t have the ring he’s after.

I’m very upset. Look at all of these people gathered here, and not one of them commented on my outfit.

Upon hearing that Mundo isn’t the right Hobbit, Eogan jumps up, laughs at us, and dashes away through the wall of fire.

What? No I’m not kidding. Yes, that’s actually what happened. Eogan got up and ran off. Yes, I know he was dead. I stabbed him myself. No, I’m not just making crap up to make this seem more interesting.

You really don’t believe me? What’s your problem, here? Haven’t we been honest with each other so far?

Ok, fine. Look: You brought this on yourself:

EOGAN GETS UP.

EOGAN GETS UP.

EOGAN GETS UP.

TAUNTS US.

TAUNTS US.

TAUNTS US.

AND RUNS AWAY.

AND RUNS AWAY.

AND RUNS AWAY.

THROUGH A FIRE.

THROUGH A FIRE.

THROUGH A FIRE.

OKAY?

Sheesh. You have serious trust issues or something.

Really, this “bad guy faked his own death and then walked away during a cutscene” crap works in a Final Fantasy game, but this sort of cheesy plot hack feels completely out of place in Lord of the Rings. Usually the writing in this game is quite good (my cruel lampooning aside) but this whole scene is a traffic jam of exposition and dialog set amidst what is supposedly a battle in a burning city.

Hey look, Jon Brackenbrook is here.

So, Jon. Feeling pretty good about your decision to wait until after nightfall?

So, Jon. Feeling pretty good about your decision to wait until after nightfall?

Not that he helped or anything. In fact, he let Eogan walk right by him. Suddenly I realize he’s probably grief-stricken because he just lost his dad. Moreover, I seem to be standing on his dad’s corpse.

Stepping deftly off the mustachioed cadaver, I go over to Jon and do my best to comfort him, “Jon, I’m really sorry your dad was such a terrible captain and inept soldier, although perhaps realizing this will make his rather timely death easier to bear.”

Well, this entire ordeal has been a complete debacle. The only silver lining on the entire affair is that Amdir left our side and joined up with the bad guys. Once the Nazgul realize just how useless he is, they are going to feel very stupid for wasting so much time trying to enslave him.

Sorry if this one is a bit of a downer. “A village burns down and everyone dies” is a pretty tough set-up for jokes, actually.

So maybe this is a bad time to ask, but... do you have any fancy clothes for me?

So maybe this is a bad time to ask, but... do you have any fancy clothes for me?

Someone really should do something about these fires.

Next Time: Bong! Bring out your dead!

Enjoyed this post? Please share!



11Just 11 comments.

From the Archives:

  1. Awwww, poor City of Heroes…

  2. Dreadjaws says:

    So, Shamus, going through your old articles you mentioned you had plans to maybe do one of these series for Guild Wars 2. Did you decide not to, forgot about it or just didn’t post it here and saved it for The Chosen One?

    Because it’d be fun to have another one of these. Videos are fun and all, but I like these better.

    • Bubble181 says:

      Between the Mass Effect stuff, these reposts, the Good Robot posts (his, Rutskarns and Arvids), and Experienced Points, us text-preferring fans are currently really being treated. I love it.

      I do agree that (perhaps after GR has launched and the work surrounding it has died down a bit?) some form of Let’s Play or text series would be nice; especially a humorous/fun/light one (the programming, ME, DRM posts are great reads and always have some humor in them, but it’s not quite the same, is it? :-) )

    • Ahiya says:

      Shamus doing a GW2 series would be brilliant. I’d even watch that if he decided to do a video Let’s Play.

  3. These bring back such fond (and not so fond) memories of the early days of lotro. Kinda wish Shamus had done a dwarf or elf series too, there were fewer spiders and more goblins, as I recall, as well as some dwarves forgetting lunch. Also a dwarf leader who couldn’t tell the difference between an elf and a dwarf but they got him laser eye surgery in a patch.

    Ruts’s Battlespire (and the Battle Bowl series before it and well, pretty much all of his Let’s Plays) are hysterical and I love ’em, but I do miss Shamus’s too.

  4. Taellosse says:

    … I think this whole scene is a traffic jam of exposition and dialog set amidst what is supposedly a battle in a burning city.

    Usually the writing in this game is quite good (my cruel lampooning aside) but this scene is a bit of an exposition traffic jam.

    This is mostly just a repost, I know, so maybe not worth any significant editing, but it seems like the last sentence of that first paragraph and the solitary concluding sentence of the block could be combined and feel less redundant. “Exposition traffic jam” is a good phrase, but it feels clumsy getting used twice so close together, to me. The whole thing could probably just say, “Usually the writing in this game is quite good (my cruel lampooning aside), but I think this whole scene is a traffic jam of exposition and dialog set amidst what is supposedly a battle in a burning city.” and leave the block at a single paragraph.

    Not that you asked for another editor from 6 years in the future. Sorry.

  5. Drlemaster says:

    I actually ran through this area last weekend. They seem to have updated things to be slighly less stupid. I had to gather berries, but it was so Celandine could make tea for Amdir. And I don’t think Calder Cobb is the one in jail. But you still wait until the town is all on fire before helping during the final assault, and Amdir still runs off with some red-robed junior nazgul, so there are still issues. In fact, I don’t remember fighting the Eogan guy. I think he just shows up, runs off with Amdir, and then I fight Calder Cobb. But I was shooting everyone from a distance, so I didn’t always know what bad guy I was fighting.

  6. Tuvalu says:

    Yeah, Eogan no longer exists. Calder Cob fights the captain and two red “Cargûl” wraiths (yes, Cargûl means Red Wraith) come in to take Amdir away. It’s still kinda cutsceney, but no one fakes their own death and they at least give you a reason you can’t do anything about it.

Leave a Reply

Comments are moderated and may not be posted immediately. Required fields are marked *

*
*

Thanks for joining the discussion. Be nice, don't post angry, and enjoy yourself. This is supposed to be fun.

You can enclose spoilers in <strike> tags like so:
<strike>Darth Vader is Luke's father!</strike>

You can make things italics like this:
Can you imagine having Darth Vader as your <i>father</i>?

You can make things bold like this:
I'm <b>very</b> glad Darth Vader isn't my father.

You can make links like this:
I'm reading about <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Darth_Vader">Darth Vader</a> on Wikipedia!

You can quote someone like this:
Darth Vader said <blockquote>Luke, I am your father.</blockquote>