Foremost Message

  By Shamus   Jun 8, 2007   27 comments

James Lilek’s new blog at Buzz.mn is already dealing with F1RST P0ST! issues. He suggests a “disabling jolt of electricity” for anyone first-posting his site, but I notice comment #1 is just such a post.

It’s time to respond in kind: I’m going to senselessly delete the very first comment on this post, no matter what it is. :)

UPDATE: And the victim was Telas, whose musings are now lost forever, alas. Seems sort of stupid now, but I promised. who cheated by double posting. Curse you Telas! I’ll get you for this!

20727 comments. Hurry up and add yours before it becomes passé.


  1. Telas says:

    Fark.com converts “first post” into “boobies”.

    For a while, they were changing the time on any post with “first post” to add a few hours to it.

  2. Vasay says:

    Yay! Delete me! )

  3. Vasay says:

    Actually I can go around your “measures” by doubleposting! :P

  4. Telas says:

    I just posted twice. Back button, “Submit Comment”.

    And yes, you’re probably going mad as well… :D

  5. Shamus says:

    And then, while fumbling around in control panel, I managed to delete my OWN comment, where I asked Telas if the comment was double-posted. So… The only person to TRULY have their comment deleted, was me.

  6. Telas says:

    Teh Intarwebs are fun!!11eleventy-one

  7. Vasay says:

    So you see, Shamus, that this won’t work :)
    And if you would delete every first comment, then next one would become first, and you would end up deleting ALL comments :) //that’s a programmer’s side of view ^__^

  8. Alexis Li says:

    On the subject of ‘boobies’… my software product uses the (.) operator. It means, pass the current context to this XPath function. We do affectionately call it the nipple operator, although I don’t think it’s made it into any official design documentation yet (we don’t have any, which makes it easier to be sure).

    boobies.

  9. Robert says:

    You misspelled “senselessly”. Other errors include

    *** disabling jolt of electricity ***

    Ow, that really stings.

  10. Alan Post says:

    slashdot, when it originally encountered this problem, added an automatic first comment to their blog that said “first post!”

    i’ve no idea how effective it was… anyone care to weigh in on that?

  11. Aaron M says:

    Personally, if I had a blog that attracted “first!” comments, any such would result in a permaban.

  12. AngiePen says:

    Aaron M — ditto, or the LJ equivalent, anyway. [vehement nod] Luckily the people who comment on my journal aren’t into that, for which I am eternally grateful.

    Angie

  13. SimeSublime says:

    I have to say, any measure to get rid of the annoying ‘first posters’ would be nice. I often miss out on interesting discussions here because I’m dissuaded by the first few rubbish competition posts.

  14. Cenobite says:

    I CAN HAS DISABLIN JOLT UF LECTRITY?

  15. Luser says:

    I like Alan’s idea at number 10.

    Somehow “First post after the automatice first post!!” just doesn’t have the zing of a “real” first post.

  16. Ian says:

    In the rare event that I add a new category to my forum, it’s inevitable that someone will make a topic called “FIRST” just for the sake of postcount++. I’ve been countering it by making the section admin-only until I have time to nip it at the bud and do it myself. ;)

  17. Matt` says:

    Whatever measures are used to try and take the zing out of it, if they’re known to be in use then people will just compete to get the first “real” post

    The Slashdot solution is pretty clever though, good example of techy style lateral thinking

  18. Winged Ignorance says:

    Alan Post says:
    “slashdot, when it originally encountered this problem, added an automatic first comment to their blog that said “first post!”

    i’ve no idea how effective it was… anyone care to weigh in on that?”

    Somehow, I think this would be even more insulting to “first post!” types than actually deleting the comment would be. Some might not even realize it’s an automatic thing and would go insane hitting f5 on the blog to try and beat this imaginary foe.

  19. Mordaedil says:

    This is hilarious.

  20. Dreamy McSleepland says:

    I think the word “First” in any first post should be replaced by a photo of Bill Frist with the word FRIST! over it.

  21. Winged Ignorance says:

    Perhaps a good old-fashioned word filter is in order, set to apply only to the first post? Just enter common combinations of words used by “first post!” types (such as “first post!” “first comment!” “f1rst p0st!” or whatever).

    Or you could do something where if the first comment is under a certain number of characters — in this case, between 11 and 15 (depending on how much punctuation is used), the body is replaced by something very insulting message. Or, in a more extreme case, automatically bans that user.

    I think the last one is what I’d do. If the first comment is under 11 characters long, it gets replaced by an extremely rude and mean message, examples of which I will not elaborate on.

  22. Harvey says:

    IMAO.us (the other site I post at) went through a “First!” phase, but it seems to have disappeared.

    Truth be told, I kinda miss it :-)

  23. Telas says:

    If the first comment is under 11 characters long, it gets replaced by an extremely rude and mean message, examples of which I will not elaborate on.

    I’ll go there. Have it say, “I don’t have a life, so I try to get “first post” status on message boards.”

    And then change the date code to +1 hour.

  24. Winged Ignorance says:

    “And then change the date code to +1 hour.”

    Your ideas intrigue me and I wish to subscribe to your newsletter.

  25. Raka says:

    I’m surprised that we haven’t seen a “last post!” craze. Even if it was popular for no more than a week or two, it would bring the comment-enabled interweb to its knees.

  26. Nefke says:

    Once it is known that ´first post´ is automated, wouldn´t everyone be going crazy to get the second?

  27. -Chipper says:

    It could be a fun 1 minute or less diversion per post for the author of this sort blog to attach the first comment to each post from a set of made-up posters making benign comments like “great comic, loved panel 3″, “lol!!”, etc. If he keeps it secret, it might take away a lot of the ‘first’ silliness.

Leave a Reply

Comments are moderated and may not be posted immediately. Required fields are marked *

*
*

Thanks for joining the discussion. Be nice, don't post angry, and enjoy yourself. This is supposed to be fun.

You can enclose spoilers in <strike> tags like so:
<strike>Darth Vader is Luke's father!</strike>

You can make things italics like this:
Can you imagine having Darth Vader as your <i>father</i>?

You can make things bold like this:
I'm <b>very</b> glad Darth Vader isn't my father.

You can make links like this:
I'm reading about <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Darth_Vader">Darth Vader</a> on Wikipedia!