DMotR Reviewed

By Shamus Posted Friday May 18, 2007

Filed under: Links 4 comments

A couple of sites have taken the time to write thoughtful reviews of my comic.

Thanks for that.

LATER: Link fixed. Whoops.

 


 

DM of the Rings CII:
A Minor Omission

By Shamus Posted Friday May 18, 2007

Filed under: DM of the Rings 160 comments

The DM forgot to bestow Aragorn’s sword.
Continue reading ⟩⟩ “DM of the Rings CII:
A Minor Omission”

 


 

DM of the Rings CI:
There He Goes Again

By Shamus Posted Wednesday May 16, 2007

Filed under: DM of the Rings 98 comments

Pippin swipes the Palantir.
Continue reading ⟩⟩ “DM of the Rings CI:
There He Goes Again”

 


 

Final Fantasy XII: Level Up

By Shamus Posted Tuesday May 15, 2007

Filed under: Game Reviews 115 comments

There are two aspects that most people talk about when discussing Final Fantasy games: The story, and the gameplay. In my previous posts I said I was unhappy with both. I’ve started the game over, and I’m still not happy with the story, but this time through the gameplay is really working for me.

In previous FF games, I’d march straight through the game, occasionally taking little half-hour leveling sessions to level up a bit past the monsters and ease my way past the occasional bossfight. This usually worked well. I was doing that here, and wondering why the game was so murderously hard.
Continue reading ⟩⟩ “Final Fantasy XII: Level Up”

 


 

Guiding player movement

By Shamus Posted Tuesday May 15, 2007

Filed under: Tabletop Games 40 comments

dd_bolwood.jpg
It was interesting reading the various comments from people on yesterday’s comic. The problem of railroading players vs. letting wander into undefined areas is apparently pretty common. I thought I’d mention how I handled this in my own games, which I’ve previously mentioned in the wrap-up post to our most recent D&D campaign.

When I do wilderness travel, I sort of make it a branching maze. For example: “You are in a broad clearing. From here you can go east into the valley or you can ascend the large hill to the southwest. You could also turn around and return to the pine grove to the north, which you just left.” The players understand that I’m presenting them with choices that are likely, given the terrain. Sure, they could choose some unlikely course of action, like going halfway up a hill and then walking around, but this will be slower, pointless, and they will just end up at a recycled version of one of my established locations anyway. This gives them a bit of freedom, and makes wilderness seem less arbitrary. Some ways are faster, some can be very slow (like a valley which gets thick with vegitation once they enter) and some can have encounters.

I really like this system. It lets players move around more or less freely, but still has enough structure so that the DM can keep track of where you’re going, where you’ve been, and how long it took to get there. For difficult topography like swamps and dense jungle I make the waypoints very close together, so that many movements are needed to cover a small area. If they are traveling over wide open grasslands, I’ll make the dots very far apart. I usually space them based on time, so that traveling from one waypoint to the next takes a couple of in-game hours. When the players have gone through a few of them and I tell them the sun is setting, they will actually have a sense that in-game time has passed.

This offers a nice theoretical “wall” around your gameworld. When the players say they want to go west and leave the game area, you give them a few waypoints of increasingly difficult swamp / desert / cliffs / mountains / jungle. If they are actually roleplaying, they will have to ask themselves, “would our characters really be wading through this crap for no good reason?” If they keep going and enter the blank, empty areas of the map, they shouldn’t be surprised at the lack of towns and other interesting locations. Who would build a city in a swamp?

 


 

DM of the Rings C:
Railroad Goes Ever on and on

By Shamus Posted Monday May 14, 2007

Filed under: DM of the Rings 171 comments

Lets go somewhere different.
Continue reading ⟩⟩ “DM of the Rings C:
Railroad Goes Ever on and on”

 


 

Final Fantasy XII: Too Clever to be Understood

By Shamus Posted Sunday May 13, 2007

Filed under: Game Reviews 57 comments

Hey, remember when I ran out of the room and let you guys all get captured? Yeah, I was just messing with you.  Pretty funny, huh?
Hey, remember when I ran out of the room and let you guys all get captured? Yeah, I was just messing with you. Pretty funny, huh?
After my initial post on FFXII I realized I needed to lower my expectations if I want to enjoy this game. It’s not a terrible game. If it wasn’t carrying the Final Fantasy banner I would have been a lot more accepting of its shortcomings. It’s just that I was expecting FINAL FREAKIN FANTASY here, and for me it was falling short of that lofty ideal.

In the comments yesterday several people said they found the politics and scheming in this game to seem small and uninteresting alongside the planet-smashing threats we’ve faced in the past. I said the same thing at one point, but after reading responses from people who like the plot I can see there probably is a gripping tale here. There isn’t any real reason a war and struggle for freedom can’t be just as thrilling as fighting Jenova and Sepheroth or Sin and Seymore, as we did in games past.

The problem here isn’t the scope, it’s the presentation. Continue reading ⟩⟩ “Final Fantasy XII: Too Clever to be Understood”