Fan Service

By Shamus Posted Friday Apr 14, 2006

Filed under: Anime 22 comments

fledgling otaku posed a question in the comments of this post. He was asking about “fan service” vs. “geek service”. I started to write a response, went off topic, and then realized that the comment thread is already miles long. So I’m just going to move the discussion to a new post. This hits on something I’ve had in my list of stuff to write about for a while now anyway, and this gives me a good excuse to set it all down.

Personally, I don’t mind fan service as long as it is part of a good story and interesting characters. I watch anime with my wife, and she doesn’t mind it either – if the story is good. Fan service for its own sake isn’t something either of us cares to watch, but I think that’s true of most fans.

Newcomers are sometimes shocked at fan service. (I was) It’s certainly unexpected to American viewers who grew up with the idea that cartoons are for kids. But after seeing quite a bit of anime I’m noticing that the Japanese have very different ideas on what should and should not be shown, and in some ways are more reserved than Americans. For example, despite the more lax standards the Japanese have towards nudity or revealing clothing, I can’t think of a single series where the characters actually had sex. I don’t think it has ever happened in any show I’ve watched, not even off-camera. Nobody talks about, or admits to, having sex. Compare this to many American shows where we don’t see the characters naked, but most of the sub-plots involve complex stories of who’s having sex with whom. Even American dramas aimed at young adults and teens (90210 or Dawson’s Creek type stuff) have webs of changing partners and continuous infidelity. I find this to be endlessly tiresome, so for me Anime is pretty refreshing and a lot less objectionable.

Another amusing thing about this is the way the Japanese handle the for-television shows where nudity is required by the story. Instead of using scenery to obscure the forbidden parts they sometimes simply leave them off. I’m thinking now to Ai Yori Aoshi, where the characters are built like Barbie and Ken when we see them “naked”. It’s an interesting way to handle things. Of course, it’s only possible using animation. You couldn’t get away with that in a live-action show. (ewwww)

We’re going to be watching Najica Blitz Tactics in a week or so. It looks enough like the excellent Noir to capture our interest, but the series is also notorious for its copious supply of panty shots. We’ll see how the balance plays out.

For my own site, I try to keep things more or less family friendly. My kids are sometimes in the room when I’m writing, so I don’t post stuff I wouldn’t want them to see. So, no Ecchi. Mireille and Kirika in short skits is fine, but I’m not going to be posting Mahoro deploying her brassiere launcher. I don’t think I want to try to explain that one to the kids. Or anyone else.

 


 

Wikipedia Meme

By Shamus Posted Friday Apr 14, 2006

Filed under: Links 13 comments

Random surfing led me to Tim Worstall, who had this idea:

Go to Wikipedia and look up your birth day (excluding the year). List three neat facts, two births and one death in your blog, including the year.

I won’t limit myself to the numbers above. Let’s just see what’s interesting about August 24:

Facts:

79 AD: Mount Vesuvius erupts.
1456: The printing of the Gutenberg Bible is completed.
1853: Potato chips are first prepared.
1891: Thomas Edison patents the motion picture camera.
1944: World War II: French and Allied troops start the attack on Paris.
1968: France explodes its first hydrogen bomb, thus becoming the world’s fifth nuclear power.

Births:

1817: Aleksey Konstantinovich Tolstoy
1929: Yasser Arafat
1973: David Chappelle

Deaths:

1042: Michael V, Byzantine Emperor

 


 

Spam Patterns

By Shamus Posted Friday Apr 14, 2006

Filed under: Rants 14 comments

A few items to note about comment spam:

It seems to come in waves, or cycles. Yesterday I got more spam than I have in the past week. Normally this would lead you to believe that one spammer has started pounding away at the site, but that doesn’t seem to be the case here. I wasn’t keeping count until afternoon, but I’m guessing I got about twenty or thirty so spam comments a all day, and each one seemed to come from a different IP. There were a few common types, and for my own purposes I’ve categorized them:

  • Mr. Brown-noser – Posts a plausible-looking comment like, “I agree! I hope others write about this as well! I love your site.”. It’s clumsy and generic enough to stand out, but I have to actually look at what URL they link before I chuck them in the bit bucket.
  • Mr. Lotsa Links – Obvious spam. The posts are just page after page of keywords and links.
  • Mr. Sneaky – Posts comments to really old posts with just one or two links, hoping they will escape my notice and remain for search engines to find. If I didn’t check the admin page I might miss these ones.
  • Mr. Infomercial – Has lots of “helpful facts” about whatever he’s linking, which is usually generic meds.

Each of the above has just a few variants they re-use, but these are the four distinct types I see. (Each one has other characteristics, like what types of bogus usernames and emails they provide and the type of bold / italics tags they use.)

Anyway, I wonder why the cyclical nature? It is possible that the coming long weekend (which had already arrived in some parts of the world, like Australia) provided the spammers with time off from their normal day jobs. (Clubbing baby seals, most likely.)

Maybe its just a coincidence. Maybe my site has propigated to another group of them.

Sometimes I block the IP of one of these spammers if I already have the admin window open. However, I suspect this is a waste of time. I’m wondering if these changing IP’s aren’t from guys who are using wireless hotspots or internet cafes to do their dirty deeds. If this is the case, then blocking them is a waste of time, and in fact creates a (very, very slight) chance that a legit visitor will arrive on the same address at some point and get rejected.

 


 

Everyone else is doing it!

By Shamus Posted Thursday Apr 13, 2006

Filed under: Nerd Culture 24 comments

Just about everyone knows that Steven Den Beste used to blog a lot about politics, but has since quit and started blogging about Anime.

I used to run this pseudohumorous political satire site, but gave it up and now run the goofy blog you are currently reading.

Now I learn that the excellent haibane.info is run by Aziz Poonawalla, and it looks like Dean Esmay has joined him.

What’s with all the political bloggers going geek? What’s next?

Maybe Glenn Reynolds will give up on his regular blog and start a Najica Blitz Tactics-themed site: InstaPanties.com

As if he needs any more readers.

 


 

Lightsaber Duel

By Shamus Posted Thursday Apr 13, 2006

Filed under: Nerd Culture 5 comments

You may remember the post from a few days ago where I had a major geek-out and mused about how real lightsabers might be used.

If that didn’t seem too geeky for you, then you may want to check out this movie.

A couple of hobbyists got together and produced a five-minute feature of the two of them having a lightsaber battle. Unlike some of the fan-made stuff I’ve seen, this has a lot of polish to it and is really exciting. Their movements are quick and sure, and the special effects look professional. My only quibble is the location. They are in some sort of industial setting (which is good) but it looks a little too bright in there. The overhead fluro lights conflict with the lightabers in the forground. If the background lights could have been dimmed, this would look even better.

Having said that, it’s amazing what these guys accomplished. They play it mostly straight (this isn’t a parody) but they inject a little humor into things, along with a nicely varied fight that keeps things interesting.

It amazes me how cheaply this can be done these days. The other interesting thing is that right now the software required is going to cost a lot more than the hardware. In every fan-made lightsaber movie I’ve seen, they use Adobe Premiere for editing, which costs a lot more than the average consumer-grade video camera. Still, for a little over a thousand bucks you can get the tools required to make a movie like this. After that, all you need is talent, hard work, money for props, a couple of actors and a near endless supply of free time.

 


 

Sugar: Note to Saga

By Shamus Posted Wednesday Apr 12, 2006

Filed under: Anime 7 comments

I’m thinking back to disc 2 of Sugar, A Little Snow Fairy. In one episode, Sugar writes a message in crayon for Saga and shows it to her. But she writes on a treasured piece of sheet music that belonged to Saga’s deceased mother, so Saga gets upset and doesn’t read the message right away. She carries the paper around with her, and looks at it later, and yet she still doesn’t read it. She’s old enough to read a message this short without any problem, just by glancing at it.

Later she shows it to Salt and Pepper and they look right at it and read it to her. They tell her it says ” Sorry Saga “, which she should have been able to read herself.

I can only conclude that the only reason she didn’t read it is because she couldn’t, and the only reason for that is that it isn’t in her native language.

Looking at the letters, they are not German (the story takes place in Germany, I think) or indeed any other European language. They don’t look very Japanese, either. In fact, they look kinda… made-up. So, is it:

  • A pretend European language, or faux-German? (Like the way Americans might make fake Japanese by drawing squiggles that look Japanese to them.) Unlikely. It shouldn’t have been hard for the animators to translate a two-word message into German. They went all the way to Germany to do research for the series, so I don’t think they would glaze over a detail like this.
  • A language I don’t recognize? I don’t think so. The language looks quite pictographic, but it also looks much too long for the information it contains. Also, the message seems to change shape a bit and is always partly obscured, so I expect we aren’t supposed to examine it too closely. In any case, this doesn’t explain why Saga couldn’t read it.
  • A special made-up Fairy language? This would explain why Salt and Pepper could read it and Saga couldn’t. This seems most likely, but why would Sugar expect Saga to be able to read Fairy writing?

BUT: Then I get to disc 5 and Elder has a cookie for Ginger:

So what we have are characters who live in Germany, speak Japanese, and write in gibberish on paper but use English when writing on cookies. I’m sure I’m just reading to much into this, but I can’t help feeling like I’m missing something.

 


 

iRant

By Shamus Posted Wednesday Apr 12, 2006

Filed under: Rants 7 comments

Steven Den Beste takes Apple to task for their QuickTime installer. This hits a nerve with me, so I find I must add the following insightful commentary:

Yeah. Everything he said.

It’s too late to help Steven, but I want to mention that recently I managed to stumble on the page that let me install the Player and not ITunes. It never even mentioned iTunes during the process. It was shortly after getting this computer that I visited Lileks and tried to watch one of his home movies. The page I was sent to from there gave me just the player, not iTunes. I can’t find that particular page through Apple’s site though.

On my old computer I had iTunes, and it was every bit as annoying as Steven says. The various “helper” processes running in the background infuriated me. The worst was the iPod app. Why is this thing running by default? If the user doesn’t own an iPod, then this is just wasted memory, CPU cycles, hard drive space, and (worst of all) needless clutter in the list of running applications. If they DO have an iPod, well then wouldn’t they install the iPod software that came with the unit? There is no reason for this process to even exist, much less run in the background all the time.

But more important is the principle of the thing. Sure, the “helper” apps only take up a measly 6 meg of memory. I’m sure I can’t percieve the change in performance over 6 meg, but what if everyone did this? If every application grabbed 6 meg and added two processes to the soup, my computer would be an unusable mess with hundreds of processes clogging up the works. What makes Apple think they have the right to do this? What makes them so special?

iTunes is like a nest of bad weeds. The roots go deep, and no matter what you do you’ll never feel like you got them all. It’s worse than MediaPlayer by a long shot, which is really saying something. It’s like a race to the bottom with these two. Shameful.

And finally: I’m sick of the fights over file types between QT and MP as well. Each program tries to poach the file types native to the other player. Both are guilty of it, although QT earns my ire for the time it stole the MPEG associations and then was unable to play the files when I clicked on them. Very naughty.