Wrong DVD label, Part 2

By Shamus Posted Wednesday Jun 21, 2006

Filed under: Rants 7 comments

A few days ago I mentioned that Netflix had shipped me a disc which had been incorrectly burned, and the label of the disc and the data it contained did not match. We sent it back, and requested another copy. As I feared, this second copy has the same problem.

So the disc label says it is Last Exile: Disc 4, but the data on the Disc is for Last Exile: Disc 3. Netflix has ways for you to let them know that they sent the wrong disc, and ways to let them know that the disc is scratched or broken, but there is no way to tell them about this particular problem. When the movie gets back to Netflix, there is no way to tell them that they should not put the disc back into circulation.

We did the best we could. My wife put sticky notes on the disc and sleeve describing the problem. Will this do any good? I doubt it. I’m sure these things are opened by some poor sod who sits there all day tearing open envelopes and making sure the disc and sleeve match. I’m sure they see lots of stupid stuff all day: people accidently mailing back one of their own movies, people sending back smashed and broken discs, people sending back bootleg copies because they had retained the legitimate copy themselves, and a dozen other things that may go wrong in the process. I’m sure all sorts of people ignore the instructions and try to communicate with Netflix via these envelopes. Maybe some dim blub will include a little hand-written note, “Please send me movie XXXX”, instead of using the web interface. I know how strange things can get when dealing with a large enough group of people.

So what will they make of our sticky notes? I’d hoped that someone might read it and check their inventory, making sure the other copies of Disc 4 were ok. At worst, they would ignore the note and put the disc back into circulation. If they are truly stupid they would send me the same disc back again.

So now they have sent me a replacement for Disc 4, and it’s messed up like the previous one. It’s clear that they have a bad run of these discs. I went to the website to see if I could contact customer service / support / anything and let them know about this problem. It turns out that this cannot be done. No email. No phone number. No way to send any sort of specific message. (You can send text via the “give us feedback form” but I’m sure that info isn’t going to go anywhere useful.) The only real interface is a “report a problem” multiple-choice form, which doesn’t provide any way for me to tell them what is really wrong. There is no way to convey that the disc is bad unless it is scratched. I’m sure if I keep reporting Disc 4 is scratched over and over, they will think I’m the one doing something wrong.

I’ve always praised Netflix, but now I see they have a rather nasty flaw: Their system is incapable of dealing with unexpected problems.

I took a permanant marker and put a tiny little dot on the most recent disc, and I’ll see if I get the same one back. This would be an amusing experiment if I wasn’t deprived of my Last Exile in the meantime.



From The Archives:

7 thoughts on “Wrong DVD label, Part 2

  1. I wonder if, deliberately or inadvertently, they sent you exactly the same DVD again?

  2. Sorry, I should have finished reading before I posted my comment. It looks like you thought of that possibility yourself.

  3. Acksiom says:

    Well, I could go by their offices out here in silicon valley, and actually tell someone in person, what with how I drive past there once or twice a week after changing my mother’s sheets at her board-and-care.

    It would be my pleasure; just say the word.

    BTW, did you not get my email about the KamBakZa flash movies?

  4. Shamus says:

    BTW, did you not get my email about the KamBakZa flash movies

    No. Sigh. I can only assume my Thunderbird spam filter caught it. I don’t see anything with “Acksiom” anywhere on it. What was the subject line?

  5. Acksiom says:

    LOL. Well, first of all, it wouldn’t be under that name, but my full one.

    But, okies, gimme a minute here. . .checking Sent file. . .

    . . .uhhhhh. . .

    “Dude. Like, totally groove on this:”

    FINE. I can see how a high-standards spam filter might choke on that.

    . . .-ing spammers. . . .

    Anyhoo. Forwarded the original to you.

    Also, I promise to be the happy, dewey-cheeked, jolly fat ‘gosh-wow!’ internet geek should I go by the local Netflix offices on your behalf, i.e., ‘Wow, isn’t it so cool that we can communicate and solve problems like this!”

    As opposed to, say, the antagonistic ‘Fix my friend’s problem, biznatches!” poor-impulse-control model of behavior that one might reasonably expect based upon people’s general intarweb behavior.

  6. I finally gve up and marked the disk as unplayable on their site so now they can send us a new copy and we can see if its just this disk or if all are messed up that way. As far as I am concerned it is unplayable. That disk, marked Last Exile, Disk 4 does not in any way play Last Exile disk 4. At this point the fact that it does play disk 3 no longer matters since we tried to tell them for their own sakes and they didn’t listen. My thinking is that they could have put a “disk 3” label on it and had an extra disk 3 or as Shamus mentioned if it was Oblivion’s fault they coud have sent it back to them and they could have fixed it. Either way, by ignoing our notes they lost out.

    Keep in mind, in the past we have placed notes on disks and they have no ignored them so I assume that they just thought it inconceivable that we be right and ignored it.

  7. Anachronda says:

    Yeah, I noticed the lack of real contact info on their website. In my case, I thought they might want to know that every envelope I get from the Bakersfield shipping center arrives late and mangled and that they might want to look into their equipment there.

    But I guess not.

Thanks for joining the discussion. Be nice, don't post angry, and enjoy yourself. This is supposed to be fun. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked*

You can enclose spoilers in <strike> tags like so:
<strike>Darth Vader is Luke's father!</strike>

You can make things italics like this:
Can you imagine having Darth Vader as your <i>father</i>?

You can make things bold like this:
I'm <b>very</b> glad Darth Vader isn't my father.

You can make links like this:
I'm reading about <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Darth_Vader">Darth Vader</a> on Wikipedia!

You can quote someone like this:
Darth Vader said <blockquote>Luke, I am your father.</blockquote>

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *