Sims 4 Overthinking: Good Bones

By Bay Posted Friday Feb 17, 2023

Filed under: Epilogue, The Sims Overthinking 17 comments

The year is 2000, Lorretta Whitman is 55 years old, and she has just inherited 1605 Cottonview Lane, the house built by her grandparents in the early ’20s. She is going twice a week to Jimbo’s apartment to cook, clean, and help keep his medications organized for him.

He thinks it’s pity, but she’s worried it’s selfish. She doesn’t want to be at home. Home is quiet, and a little unsettling. She and her husband have two daughters who have now gone off to university. With the girls gone, it’s been hard for her to ignore the growing sense of distance and resentment she shares with the man she married. Instead, she has thrown herself into as many little jobs as she can.

She works for a dry cleaning agency once a week, just helping out an old friend. She goes to Jimbo’s twice a week to help him out. She goes on overly long grocery trips, and makes care packages for her out-of-state children. Anything to be out of the house. She offers to drive down to visit one of her daughters, but she is quickly and politely shut down. Her girls are learning to be their own independent people, they don’t need her right now. Unfortunately, that doesn’t stop her from missing them. She offers to take Jimbo grocery shopping with her once a week and get him out of the house, and he gladly accepts.

The day Lorretta was given the house, she went inside and explored it a bit. The smell was awful, the carpets ruined, the walls yellowed with tar. She is thankful for the gesture but unsure what to do with the place. She had suggested to her husband that they might fix it up, to sell or give to one of the girls down the line, but he was having none of it. He grumbled about it being too much work, too big of a money sink, and that it wasn’t the time to get into real estate. Lorretta admitted she didn’t know much about the property market, and he agreed with her a little too emphatically.

It was only when he suggested that they just sell it and get it out of the way, that she put her foot down. He considered it a sink on their taxes and something that was about to tank in value. She considered it a family heirloom and a very kind gift, she didn’t feel right just turning it in for a quick buck. They argued, as they usually did, and then left the matter unresolved.

With their daughters out of the house, Mr. Whitman grows more and more comfortable snapping and grouching out loud. It used to be that Lorretta could point out that they shouldn’t argue in front of the children, but without children to argue in front of, that reasoning is gone. Slowly, it’s as if twenty-two years of not arguing in front of the children is all coming out at once, the fighting becomes more regular and vile.

The next time Lorretta steps into the old house is on November 23rd of 2001, just an hour after giving her husband divorce papers.

She doesn’t get very much done, but it’s cathartic to paint and get some energy out of her system.

Unfortunately for her, painting in a state of distress can cloud judgment and perception. The next week when she returns with a clearer head, she will discover she was painting over peeling wallpaper. What idiot put up orange wallpaper?

Lorretta returns to her maiden name; Cooper, the married name her own mother, Betty had held until she died.

The splitting of assets is messy, Mr. Whitman is bitter about the divorce and Lorretta just wants it over with. They argue about their two properties, the house they bought together and the home that Lorretta inherited. He suggests again that they sell, this time to liquidate and split the proceeds. Lorretta refuses. He suggests in a fit of frustration that they each take a house, him keeping their old married home, and her getting the broken-down garbage that had been left to her.

Much to his, and maybe even Lorretta’s surprise, she agrees with him.

Their money is split, their car is sold, everything they have is appraised and valued and inspected. Life is messy and up in the air and angry, and then, all at once, 1605 Cottonview Lane is Lorretta’s only home.

They have no young children to shuffle back and forth, and no pets to fight over. She doesn’t have to see him anymore if she doesn’t want to. It’s freeing, sad, and horrible all at once.

She’s been left with about thirty-five thousand dollars in the end, and a house that she feels certain will gladly eat every penny of it. Jimbo had the good sense to warn her about the water damage he covered up in the seventies before the deal closed, but either way, she accepted it. She gets the utilities turned back on, and moves into a room upstairs, deciding to spend her restless energy redoing the place. Her eldest daughter visits to help her move and expresses deep concern for the situation, but Lorretta is having none of it. “It’s got good bones, trust me.” She insists, omitting the fact that some of the bones are deeply water damaged.

For a moment, she almost believes it herself.

 


From The Archives:
 

17 thoughts on “Sims 4 Overthinking: Good Bones

  1. Octal says:

    Okay, I am VERY invested in Lorretta now. Rooting for her to successfully restore/renovate the place!

  2. Josh says:

    I am loving this series.

  3. Olivier FAURE says:

    That’s some very thought-out backstory. I’m kind of curious whether this is a writing style you use a lot?

  4. moonlup says:

    I’m really enjoying the story here.

  5. Lino says:

    This is a really interesting story. I absolutely love the idea of exploring the “life” of a house through the interactions of a family throughout the different generations.

    But is it just me or are all the men in this story utterly useless deadweights that only do terrible things :D

    1. Sartharina says:

      The husband seemed to be right about the house being too much effort and just needing to be sold.

    2. Bay says:

      I can see how that could be a takeaway, but I honestly disagree. Mrs. Smith spent Jimbo’s entire childhood telling him he wasn’t good enough, a normal parental method of the time, and, thus Jimbo ended up with an inferiority complex. Jimbo has turned it around at this point, he gave up the house when he realized what he’d done, and later warned Lorretta about the water damage he’d hid. The men aren’t useless or deadweights, but what they are is powerful. Due to the time in history we began at, we are mostly at the behest of the men’s decisions.

      The point of my characters is often that they all suck just a little bit. No one is a perfect shining hero, but none of them suck for the sake of sucking. The power imbalance here is that instead of working together, these people are all clinging to their own opinions, and the men, with most of the power to do anything, are getting their way. Lorretta’s husband was right that the house really should have just been sold, it’s going to cost an arm and a leg to fix. However, if they had taken a moment to hear each other, he might have realized how important it was to her, and she might have been willing to downsize her expectations and listen to his side.

      1. Lino says:

        Smith spent Jimbo’s entire childhood telling him he wasn’t good enough, a normal parental method of the time, and, thus Jimbo ended up with an inferiority complex.

        I don’t remember reading about that… In which part of the series do you mention it?

        In any case I really like how your story (intentionally or not) explores the way a lack of cooperation and listening to each other can create a dysfunctional family. It’s just that the story seemed a bit imbalanced, that’s all.

        1. Bay says:

          It very much is imbalanced for the reasons I stated above, it will get less so now that we travel more into modern times. But the people with the power often appear the stupidest, since they are the ones making the decisions. It isn’t a true reflection of ability or personality, simply that the women didn’t get many chances to make stupid or selfish calls thus far, because someone had to keep the kids fed and the laundry done. History books often feel imbalanced in that way. Mrs. Smiths power to mess up was mainly in child rearing, which she entirely did.

          Jimbo started with good intentions, but has gotten bitter and often spitful as time has gone on. Likely, his mom made all this worse when she was alive by constantly pointing out how he could be more like his siblings. Jeramoot had the family business and Betty had the grandchildren. He’s attached his self-esteem to owning this house, which is toxic and sad. Everyone could have done better, and now there’s an inch of cigarette tar on every interior wall of the building. Sad.

          Near the end of ‘Legal issues’ is where I mention it.

      2. Philadelphus says:

        For what it’s worth, I didn’t see it that way. It felt to me like the people were fairly realistic people, but we only get to see the side of them that interacts with the house, where they tend to make less-than-perfect decisions. We don’t get to see the potential good sides of them, like, I dunno, the Smiths being great neighbors and really active in their community or something.

  6. Ivellius says:

    Incredibly invested in this series. This has been a fun read.

  7. LizTheWhiz says:

    Rooting for Loretta. Hoping she can turn this around!

  8. Dreadjaws says:

    I don’t think her siblings would be so angry that they didn’t get to keep the house if they saw its state, but then again they probably would have sold it. Loretta seems to be the one who cared the most for its sentimental value.

  9. MaxEd says:

    Adding a story to a game where there was no (or almost no) story was how I played a lot of games in my childhood. I mostly played strategic games this way, taking control of all sides and setting up imaginary conflicts, treaties and treacheries in my mind. This way, I couldn’t really lose (and I hate losing), AND I had a story in game that was otherwise lacking in this department, which is boring. These days I play RPGs alomost exclusively, but I still imagine a lot of additional dialogues for my party.

  10. Jaloopa says:

    I’m curious whether you had this all planned out in advance or if it’s more of an ad-hoc story. Either way, it’s very engaging

  11. MelTorefas says:

    You can do it Loretta! I believe in you! Probably!

Thanks for joining the discussion. Be nice, don't post angry, and enjoy yourself. This is supposed to be fun. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked*

You can enclose spoilers in <strike> tags like so:
<strike>Darth Vader is Luke's father!</strike>

You can make things italics like this:
Can you imagine having Darth Vader as your <i>father</i>?

You can make things bold like this:
I'm <b>very</b> glad Darth Vader isn't my father.

You can make links like this:
I'm reading about <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Darth_Vader">Darth Vader</a> on Wikipedia!

You can quote someone like this:
Darth Vader said <blockquote>Luke, I am your father.</blockquote>

Leave a Reply to Lino Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *