Sims 4 Overthinking: Jentle Disagreement

By Bay Posted Friday Jun 2, 2023

Filed under: Epilogue, The Sims Overthinking 10 comments

The year is 2007, and Lorretta is gone. Kelly and Michael are devastated, as is Logan, although him with much less understanding of what’s happened, only that grandma is gone.

Lorretta has left Kelly and Michael the house in her will, as well as half of what she had saved. Kelly’s older sister got the other half, and Lorretta’s car.

At first, who got what doesn’t seem to matter that much, in the midst of grief and funeral arrangements. Kelly and Michael aren’t celebrating getting the house, they knew that was Lorretta’s plan and it makes plenty of sense to them; they’ve been living in it for the last seven years.

Kelly’s sister, Jen, though? She doesn’t feel like it’s so fair.

She is amicable at the funeral, and polite when she sleeps on their couch overnight before starting her drive back home. It’s when Kelly gets a phone call from Jen while she’s on the road, that her feelings become clear. She doesn’t think it’s fair that her younger sister got the house, and she just got a car. She’d thought that it had been more fair, that maybe her mom had split the money between them 80/20 or 60/40 to make up for the fact Jen was missing out on a house. When she’d realized they’d gotten the same amount, though, that was a different story.

“Just because you got knocked up and dropped out of college doesn’t mean I should be punished for it!”

Jen had always been her mom’s favorite, but everything had changed when Kelly had Logan. Jen thinks that this is because Kelly gave her a grandchild. In reality, this is a failing on Lorretta’s part. She spent the last seven years repairing her relationship with Kelly, who she’d mishandled as a child, but she never stopped to realize she’d messed up with Jen too. Jen had been more suited personality-wise to Lorretta’s parental failings, and so had seemed to ‘come out fine’ from it. More than that, putting in work with Kelly meant she had coasted with Jen, letting their relationship fall to the wayside, even up to her death. Lorretta never stopped to realize it had damaged both of her girls. And now, it’s too late.

Jen thinks that her mom stopped caring about her because she didn’t give her grandchildren, and it’s coming out as vile comments to her sister about the whole thing. Jen is unkind, and angry, and hurt. Her sister has gotten a house to raise her child in, and Jen has gotten a car which is no better or worse than what she has now. She knows she’s being cruel, but she can’t stop herself.

Worse than that, there isn’t much Kelly can do, either. Inheriting the house comes with taxes and costs, she needs the money her mom has left her to deal with that. She doesn’t need all of it, mind you, but she also has a son to think about. Giving up some of her inheritance would affect him. And more than that, she doesn’t want to give her sister anything, because her sister is hurling abuse at her. It’s hard to want to be kind to someone hurting when they’re actively taking it out on you.

When Jen finally hangs up, Kelly is left in tears. They could move on to repair this, they could do better and talk it out. Kelly could explain why their mom left her the same amount, and Jen could explain how she can’t have children, and how she feels abandoned for it. The favoritism wasn’t malicious, it was a slow build of situations that left Lorretta not realizing what her eldest needed. But now it’s too late for Lorretta to do better, and both of her girls are too upset to try.

Jen and Kelly don’t talk about it, and slowly it becomes clear that their bridge is burned.


From The Archives:

10 thoughts on “Sims 4 Overthinking: Jentle Disagreement

  1. MrGuy says:

    I read a quote somewhere that “You will never really know another person until you have shared an inheritance with them.”

    I’ve seen more proof this is true than that it is false.

    1. Zaxares says:

      While my parents are still alive, they have sat both me and my brother down and told us that they will divide everything between us equally. On the surface, yes, this is very fair and probably the best course of action going forward to eliminate any accusations of favoritism. On the other hand, my brother spent probably a good decade and a half being supported by my parents as he tried one failed business venture after another, and although my parents don’t talk about it, I know that at one point they had to spend a considerable sum of money to bail him out after one particularly bad disaster. To be fair to my brother, his fortunes have finally turned around and he is now very successful. (Like, WAY more successful than me.) And he has been quite generous with trying to repay my parents for their support over the years, and as a de facto carer for my parents now, I’ve also benefitted from that largess.

      But, to return to the original point, in all honesty, his half of the inheritance is not even 25% of his net worth now. So although I will not object to my parents’ decision in the slightest (intellectually I do understand that this is the best decision, and emotionally I do also understand that they love both of us equally), part of me does rue the fact that as someone who didn’t benefit to the same level from my parents’ support during my working life, and someone who stayed closer to home and thus became the person to attend to my parents’ needs as age began to catch up to them, it does feel like my brother got the better part of the deal.

  2. Sleeping Dragon says:

    Welp, I guess there was only so long that the good spell could have lasted.

  3. Olivier FAURE says:

    It’s like that house is cursed or something.

    1. MrGuy says:

      Yeah. Like some sort of unseen demigod is just using the house and its inhabitants to tell a story it thinks will amuse it’s friends…

      1. Zaxares says:

        Uh oh… Is the final chapter going to be one where some mysterious force has blocked off all the exits to the house and fires just start springing up everywhere?? O.o

        1. MrGuy says:

          And also there are no toilets anywhere.

  4. CliffracerX says:

    I just binged the entire Sims 4 series up to this point and my heart hurts now, danget. I was not prepared for the shift from abstract exploration of a house’s history to the deep tragedy of the dysfunctional families that have lived within it ;w;

    (Postal note to Bay- and the others who have stepped in to write for the amusement of the void: y’all rocking so far. This site has always been kryptonite for me because I will get stuck reading it for hours on end as it’s always just so GRIPPING- and it remains just the same with y’all’s storytelling and analysis. Rock on <3)

  5. Alberek says:

    Fighting Family over money is horrible

Thanks for joining the discussion. Be nice, don't post angry, and enjoy yourself. This is supposed to be fun. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked*

You can enclose spoilers in <strike> tags like so:
<strike>Darth Vader is Luke's father!</strike>

You can make things italics like this:
Can you imagine having Darth Vader as your <i>father</i>?

You can make things bold like this:
I'm <b>very</b> glad Darth Vader isn't my father.

You can make links like this:
I'm reading about <a href="">Darth Vader</a> on Wikipedia!

You can quote someone like this:
Darth Vader said <blockquote>Luke, I am your father.</blockquote>

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.