Josh Plays Shogun 2 Part 8: Diplomatic Overtures

By Josh Posted Monday Nov 7, 2011

Filed under: Spoiler Warning 42 comments


With our total victory over the Imagawa, our clan’s borders have expanded to encompass a whole host of provinces along the central Honshu coast. But few daimyo would be content with merely a few provinces when the very Shogun himself is such a tempting target, and the Oda are no exception. But a brash, reckless attempt to take Kyoto by force â€" in our current state â€" would doubtless end in complete failure. Though the coastal regions we inherited from the Imagawa have added to both our prosperity and prestige, they are not overly rich in their own right, and they would offer us little true strategic value in a war against the Shogunate.


But right on our eastern border lie the home provinces of the Hojo clan. Sagami, with its skilled smiths, could make our armies the envy of Japan. And Izu is one of the wealthiest provinces in the east, owing its prosperity to its complex of gold mines. Control of both of these provinces would not merely be a boon to our clan â€" it will be necessary in order to defeat the other great clans and establish a shogunate of the Oda. And our ninjas have revealed that neither province is particularly well defended â€" the only Hojo forces in the area are camped outside Sagami’s castle, and while they are large in number, they lack a general to lead them.

But there’s a problem.


The Murakami, the clan that conquered the mighty Takeda, is both allied with the Hojo and not very keen about us. Specifically, they seem to be unhappy with our recent successful conquest of the Imagawa and are wary of us, and they seem to be unimpressed with our clan overall. Perhaps that’s because our power is still rated as “feeble” despite controlling some 30 units of ashigaru. I think the game rates Samurai more favorably in that regard than ashigaru, regardless of whether or not the ashigaru have been beefed up to levels that would make a katana samurai sweat nervously.

Not that we’re quite there yet, but we’re not far now.

In any case, as it stands, declaring war on the Hojo would almost certainly drag the Murakami into it on their side, and while that might not mean instant death for us, it would almost certainly drag on for a long time, and leave us in a vulnerable position if someone else were to declare war on us from one of our other fronts. More than that, though, is the fact that I don’t want the Murakami land. Remember, I want to stave off triggering realm divide until I can equip armies worth of ashigaru with advanced weaponry and training. And I need to expand into the Kansai region surrounding the capital, Kyoto, as well. I’m far less worried about fighting a protracted war than I am about accidentally expanding too far.

And so, we must now turn to alternative options â€" if we could broker a diplomatic solution, perhaps we could come to an arrangement that would benefit both the Oda and the Murakami. We just need to convince them to switch sides.

This means we’ll be having our first real look at the Total War diplomacy system, which is, admittedly, pretty spartan. Total War has never had very interesting diplomacy â€" I suppose the feeling of the developers is that you should, you know, be at war in a game called “Total War.” To me that feels a bit like missing the point â€" in reality, diplomacy has never once, in human history, ceased to be a factor in warfare. “Unstoppable” war machines have been halted in their tracks simply by shifting allegiances and diplomatic overtures. And that’s not even mentioning how much better realm divide would be if it grew organically out of the game’s diplomacy system, rather than just throwing it out the window.

But I digress. Let’s see how receptive the Murakami are to talking.


I start things out by offering them a trade agreement to break the ice, which they are quick to accept.

I then throw a few offers onto the table to see how they react. The only one thing that seems to be worth breaking an alliance to them, though, is granting them unrestricted military access into our territory for 20 seasons.


The diplomacy system in this game seems to place an absurdly high value on military access, but I’ve honestly never seen the AI do much of anything with this. There aren’t any enemies they could get to from our territory that they would have any interest in conquering â€" at least, not before conquering us â€" so at this point the only thing such an arrangement would be good for would be inviting them to stab us in the back, but even then, I’ve never seen an AI really leverage the agreement to get behind any defenses either.

So it’s pretty much a “get my desired diplomatic agreement for free” card.

You may have noticed I also threw the Kiso into the “break alliance” demand â€" it didn’t really increase the cost much. But why would I do that?


Well, the Kiso are these guys. They’re pretty powerful in their own right, but they have a peaceful temperament and I think I’ve only ever seen them conquer anything outside of their one castle once or twice. But more importantly, look at the position of that castle! It’s right on top of the only road that goes directly through the massive mountain range that separates central and eastern Japan. I already control the southern coastal route, so if I had South Shinano, the only way to circumvent my defenses would be to take the northern route past Echizen and into Omi â€" by far, the longest of the three. That province is the perfect place to build up defenses, and the quarry right outside the city will reduce the cost of upgrading the castle. Its too good an opportunity to ignore.

In essence, somewhere down the line, I intend to conquer the Kiso. And it would be very nice if I didn’t have to fight the Murakami to do it.

All that said, I don’t want to break up the Hojo-Kiso-Murakami power block just yet. At this point, I’m not quite sure whether there will be any diplomatic consequences on my end for convincing the Murakami to break their alliances, and if there is, I’m not quite ready for it. I need a few seasons to rebuild our fortifications along the coast and recruit more soldiers to replace those we lost fighting the Imagawa.


Also important to note, is the Tokugawa rebels in Mikawa are still persisting. They’re unwilling to engage the castle’s defenses directly either, so they’ve been moving from one end of the province to another, raiding the province’s infrastructure. This cannot be tolerated any longer: the massive garrison I have on Mikawa â€" larger even than the one guarding Owari â€" is tying up a large amount of my military resources which would be better spent elsewhere. I need these men to keep order in other provinces so that I can resume their taxation, and I need them for the upcoming campaign against the Hojo. I’m not even going to take the time to bring Nobuhide back to Mikawa to lead them â€" these rebels need to be defeated now, and I’m not going to wait.


As you can see, we greatly outnumber the enemy, but they have better units in the form of two Yari samurai. Neither side has a general leading them, so by my reckoning, we’re about even.

This should be interesting.


The terrain we find ourselves preparing for battle upon is rough and heavily forested, which may grant the rebels something of an advantage â€" our missile superiority probably won’t be winning this battle for us. The key here will be to dislodge the Tokugawa from their defensive position and then destroy them.


Curiously, the Tokugawa do not deploy anywhere near where I thought they would â€" if you look at the above image in its full size, you can just barely see a Tokugawa flag in the distance. They’ve deployed at a far corner of the map, with their backs up to a steep cliff.



I’ve highlighted the position orders for my units here so you can see my general strategy. I want to get the enemy to focus on one of my two infantry groups (the tighter formations towards the front). The other can then swing around on a flank and surround them while the archers lay down covering fire. As much as I’ve talked up the AI in this game, it still can’t handle multiple-front battles very well at all, so I figure I can easily get the upper hand if I play this right.


As I approach the Tokugawa position, they once again surprise me â€" by retreating. They’re moving to take the hill behind them, which, I’ll admit, is a pretty good defensive position. Someone forgot to tell that poor archer unit though, because it’s standing its ground like a champ.


Incidentally, this is what it looks like when you walk two spear walls into a unit perpendicularly. And I do mean walk, yari ashigaru can’t run and maintain the spear wall formation at the same time. Instead, the march slowly towards their opponent, appearing as if an unstoppable onslaught of doom is creeping ever forward.

So those archers got killed real good.


As I approach the hill that the Tokugawa are taking refuge upon, I send my second group around the far side to hit the enemy in the flank. Of course as I do that, the Tokugawa, an ever-flowing fountain of surprises, abandon their position on the hill and charge my main line head on. So I pull my second line back to assist my main line rather than run up the side of the hill just to come all the way back down.


This turned out to be rather unnecessary, however, as the four spear walls were able to make short work of even the Tokugawa yari samurai. By the time I sent my second line back up the hill to attack the enemy archers, the fight was over.


Perhaps I’ve been giving the AI in this game too much credit, because it really shouldn’t be this easy to pull off victories like this on Legendary difficulty. A second engagement destroys what’s left of the rebels, triggering a “military crackdown” in the province which serves to largely counteract the massive “resistance to invaders” that I’ve been keeping the garrison around to deal with. I can now reorganize my troops.

As I end the turn, I get to watch this bit of hilarity:


The Hattori pool all of their troops to go fight the Tsutsui…


Only for the Hatakeyama to show up with a massive army and take Iga again. For being a clan centered around ninjas, the Hattori sure suck at scouting.


As autumn begins, we finish researching “Way of the Spear,” which means we’ve finally finished the mission we were assigned on turn two! Yay for free troops! Now we can finally focus on researching chi.

The Hojo are becoming agitated by our ninjas scouting out their territory, and I’m worried if I wait any longer to convince the Murakami to break their alliance, the Hojo will declare war and drag the Murakami into it anyway.


Unfortunately, the price has increased, and, begrudgingly, I agree to a payment of 750 koku in addition to the 20 season military access. It’s a steep price to pay, but in the end, it was probably worth it. The eastern power block of the Kiso, Murakami, and Hojo has been broken, and we can now pursue further relations with the Murakami. Having an ally to buffer us against more aggressive powers to the east could be very useful. More than that, we now have an avenue open to conquer Sagami, and with it, the province’s ever-important blacksmiths.

It looks as if things might go smoothly this time around.


From The Archives:

42 thoughts on “Josh Plays Shogun 2 Part 8: Diplomatic Overtures

  1. The Werebear says:

    What a thing to say… Things might go smoothly.

    1. Josh says:

      Oh, I’m sure nothing terrible will happen.

      1. Zombie says:

        Famous last words Josh

      2. Guus says:

        Because the Murakami are of course not going to declare war on you within the next five turns.

        1. Daemian Lucifer says:

          – So we can just sign this alliance in order to get the free blacksmiths,and then back out with no repercussions?
          – Yup….Unless,of course,war were declared.
          – Whats that?
          – War were declared.

      3. Bubble181 says:

        What’s the worst that could happen, right?

      4. Irridium says:

        That’s what I said when I started digging deep in Dwarf Fortress!

        Then the real fun began. So many clowns…

        1. Joe says:

          I’ve always thought that when somebody asks “What could possibly go wrong,” the correct answer could usually be “Dwarf fortress” followed by crying. So much crying.

          Forgotten Bea-AGHMYINTESTINES

          1. Moridin says:

            What do you mean wrong? All that means is more FUN!

          2. TSED says:


            How are MY INTESTINES coming out of ITS. SKIN?!


      5. Aldowyn says:

        personally, that “odd” in the middle of the battle (which almost seems like you put it in there because you had to have a fight, though I don’t deny it’s usefulness), seemed to foreshadow some issues with the fight. I was most definitely wrong.

        Also, I think there’s a good chance he’s SEEN what happens already. Do you do these in advance at all, Josh?

      6. Wonderduck says:

        “How hard could it be?” – Jeremy Clarkson

  2. Nidhamu says:

    If you ever get the chance Josh try playing Europa Universalis III. It’s kinda like the Total War series except it’s less focused on graphics/spectacles and more on gameplay and immersion. Lot’s of diplomacy as well, something which the Total War series lack from the beginning.

    1. Sucal says:

      Except that game is by the Hearts of Iron guys, so Josh would likely spend 99% of his time micromanaging the production of arrows, and ensuring there is enough roads and outhouses along the roads so that the carts can deliver them to the warehouses which deliver to the troops.

      If he’s spending that much time doing that, he’s spending less time delivering us the antics of his peasant uprising and attempts to snatch the pebble from the collective mass of evil samurai overlord.

      1. 4th Dimension says:

        Crusader Kings than. Basically it can become a back-stab and FAIL fest.

        1. Simulated Knave says:

          Second this. Crusader Kings is the greatest Paradox game ever – all the fun without nearly as many of the annoyances.

      2. theLameBrain says:

        Nah, you are thinking of Victoria.

        EUIII is more about compulsively monitoring how much money you mint in a year so you can keep inflation reasonable, and how big you grow your country before tech advances start coming too slowly.

        Then the pirates show up, and you can never ever get rid of them…

    2. ulrichomega says:

      I have to agree here. It’s astounding how good it feels to build a nation up from nothing in Europa Universalis III. The gameplay has been polished to a mirror over the four expansions it’s had, and it’s incredibly immersive. The AI is ruthless, and there’s very little hard coded into the game, so every game is very organic and ever changing.

  3. Sucal says:

    If there is one thing this LP is missing, its ninja antics. I might be thinking back a little to far (back to the days of Rome Total War) but no Total War LP is complete without a set of bumbling spy/assassins who end up screwing up all your plots by failing at every mission you attempt.

    1. Josh says:

      Oh, there have been a few, but none of them were terribly hilarious. It was more of a “Oh your ninja failed at something he had no chance to succeed at anyway, good for you!”

      1. Sucal says:

        No dripping over victims dress and falling down the stairs, only to drop a copy of your battle plan?

      2. Sucal says:

        Tripping* won’t let me edit

        1. Joe says:

          Shogun 2 actually has some of the best cutscenes for ninja failure, believe it or not. Failed assassination? Ninja goes to throw man from balcony. Man ducks. Failed infiltration? Ninja trips over sleeping guard. It’s kind of hilarious to watch, even if you’ve seen it all before.

  4. Zombie says:

    “A stunning victory for Roman Arms!”…… Wrong game, sorry. But It does lead to a question I have, are there advisors who tell you stuff, like Spearman are attacking your cavalry, and, I dont know what they were called, so I’m just going to call them Subordinate Officers, who tell you stuff like “The Enemy General is fleeing!”, or is it like Empire, where you were all by yourself?

      1. Daemian Lucifer says:

        Commit sudoku!That clacks me up!

  5. rofltehcat says:

    Great to see another one of those!

    About the AI and military access: I was once backstabbed by a clan and had barely any troops to defend. I gave military access to another clan who was at war with them (was more or less a stalemate with the backstabbing clan defending while the more aggressive clan breaking a few armies on the backstabber’s fortress) and that clan marched through my province, destroyed the army the backstabber originally had brought to invade my provinces and then marched on to capture two of the backstabber’s 3 or 4 provinces.
    Before the backstabbing I had originally planned to get that other clan next after finishing my offensive on my other front.

    So yeah, they can actually use it. But they rarely ask for it.
    And I guess they can’t use it for backstabbing. At least when the player declares war and has units in that clan’s provinces, those units are teleported out.

    1. Bubble181 says:

      Which, on lower difficulties anyway, is often a really good transportation method. Heh.

  6. anaphysik says:

    “Well, the Kiso are these guys. They're pretty powerful in their own right, but they have a peaceful temperament and I think I've only ever seen them conquer anything outside of their one castle once or twice.”

    A question: is it not possible to peacefully add regions/clans to your domain? (There certainly are ways IRL, intermarriage being perhaps the most well-recognized.) Or is battle the only means? I guess it seems likely, what with the weak diplomacy system.

    (Which is not to suggest that Regin- *cough* Josh would ever consider peaceful methods, of course.)

    1. 4th Dimension says:

      If you want relatively peaceful (but filled with misteriosly dead successors) overtake of a provinces, and general backstabbery, Crusader Kings might be for you.

      1. theLameBrain says:

        Ah crusader kings. The days I spent breeding nobles like they were lapdogs…

    2. rofltehcat says:

      Getting them through marriage would mean waiting for the other clan to die out (from natural causes, otherwise another clan seized the provinces), which is pretty unlikely and probably doesn’t work at all.

      You can spread your influence/religion, which causes revolts and incite revolts directly with monks/missionaries. However, those provinces then belong to rebels or new/reborn clans most of the time.
      In the Rise of the Samurai campaign you can use one of your agents to bribe a whole town but that often is extremely expensive.

      1. Nidokoenig says:

        “(from natural causes, otherwise another clan seized the provinces)”

        I take it this means having ninjas assassinate all your non-relatives in the rival clan isn’t an option? “Strange, ever since that Oda girl married into the family, everyone else has been dropping dead.” Sure, it’d be high risk and almost certainly end in disaster and annihilation, but those aren’t reasons not to do it.

        1. Grudgeal says:

          Nope. Apparently, the developers thought pruning family trees down to bare shrubbery (like the Imagawa were wont to do in the original game) was unsporting, so they removed it. Now if you kill all males in a family, the clan will simply have to do without generals until an underaged son/far-removed cousin/etc arises to become the new Damiyo. The Damiyo’s wife or son or daughter takes over command in the meantime, and you can’t sic ninjas on her.

          Basically, if you marry away a woman in Shogun 2 she now ‘belongs’ to her new family and is taken off your inheritance tree – or at least that’s my experience. The computer is generally wary with giving away their family members either way, so it’s kind of hard to test.

          1. Josh says:

            Actually it’s worse than that with the AI clans – if you kill all of the male members of the family, one will simply be auto-generated next turn in their home province to lead the clan so that the AI never doesn’t have a general for their armies.

            That said, I’m not sure how the feudal Japanese system worked in respect to maternal inheritance. I can’t recall any examples of a clan being taken over by a rival clan through intermarriage, although I can’t say whether that means it couldn’t happen or it was just uncommon in the large, powerful clans of the time.

            1. Grudgeal says:

              At least it provides easy XP farming for a skilled assassin ninja.

              As for what I remember of Japanese women’s rights, Japanese women had no inheritance rights in their clans. Clans allied or strengthened their alliances by marrying their family members to other clans, but inheritance and bloodlines was never a factor like with European royalty. A man who married a woman from another clan didn’t get any inheritance rights to that clan and the woman was considered to belong to her husband’s clan from thereon in, as were their children — and, incidentally, any other children the man may have had with other women outside of his marriage.

              Like you, I’m hard-pressed to think of any examples of marriages doing anything more than sealing military alliances (especially the Oda-Azai alliance, which subsequently got broken and is of no relevance to you in this game either way).

    3. Simulated Knave says:

      Other than declaring war then immediately offering peace in exchange for vassalization, no. And even then, you’re still declaring war – it’s just that no one has to die.

  7. Jarenth says:

    “Though the coastal regions we inherited from the Imagawa…”

    Inherited? Is that what kids are calling it these days?

  8. Chris B Chikin says:


    This isn’t the Oda Cuftbert I know!

  9. Deoxy says:

    I’m surprised you didn’t go ahead and take the “20 turns access for breaking those alliances” thing immediately – the sooner you take it (especially since it was a good deal at the time), the sooner the 20 seasons are up.

    1. Sucal says:

      I’m surprised he isn’t using the twenty turns to post troops through the other guys lands so he can immediately invade every province on turn 21.

      1. Josh says:

        The military access deal isn’t mutual – in this case, he has free access to my land but I don’t to his.

Thanks for joining the discussion. Be nice, don't post angry, and enjoy yourself. This is supposed to be fun. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked*

You can enclose spoilers in <strike> tags like so:
<strike>Darth Vader is Luke's father!</strike>

You can make things italics like this:
Can you imagine having Darth Vader as your <i>father</i>?

You can make things bold like this:
I'm <b>very</b> glad Darth Vader isn't my father.

You can make links like this:
I'm reading about <a href="">Darth Vader</a> on Wikipedia!

You can quote someone like this:
Darth Vader said <blockquote>Luke, I am your father.</blockquote>

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.